20-year-old charged with scaring woman to death

The Associated PressFebruary 2, 2009 

— Larry Whitfield was on foot, his getaway car wrecked, his rookie attempt at robbing a bank thwarted by a set of locked doors, according to detectives. Looking for a place to hide, police say, he found himself inside the home of a frightened old woman.

There's no evidence Whitfield ever touched 79-year-old Mary Parnell. Authorities say he even told the grandmother of five he didn't want to hurt her, directing her to sit in a chair in her bedroom. But investigators have no doubt he terrified her so much that she died of a heart attack.

Now Whitfield, a 20-year-old with no prior criminal record, is charged with first-degree murder, a rare defendant accused of scaring a person to death.

"He could've avoided all this by turning himself in," said Capt. Calvin Shaw of the Gaston County Police Department, which handled the investigation into Parnell's death last fall.

Under a legal concept known as the felony murder rule, it's not uncommon for prosecutors to bring a murder charge against a defendant who doesn't intentionally harm a victim. The rule exists in some form in every state and lets authorities bring murder charges when someone dies during a crime such as burglary, rape, or kidnapping.

"If you're committing any of those offenses and a person dies, that's first-degree murder," said Locke Bell, Gaston County's district attorney and the prosecutor in Whitfield's case.

Prosecutors typically use the rule to charge all of the suspects with murder when, say, one of them shoots a teller during a bank robbery. But cases of prosecutors using the felony murder rule to charge a defendant with scaring someone to death are isolated.

Jurors convicted Willie Ingram in 1982 after 64-year-old Melvin Cooper died from a heart attack in his New York home, caused by what medical experts said was the "emotional upset" of a robbery attempt. Likewise, a Pittsburgh jury convicted Mark Fisher last year in the 2003 murder of 89-year-old Freda Dale, who medical examiners said died in her home from a fear-induced heart attack.

Whitfield is being held without bail, and his attorney and his family declined to comment. He's charged with several other crimes in addition to murder, and he has not entered a plea. He faces life without parole if convicted.

Bank doors locked

Authorities said Whitfield and an accomplice, armed with semiautomatic rifles, planned to rob the Fort Financial Credit Union in Gastonia in September. The bank's staff locked its security doors as the men approached, leaving them stuck outside. They fled but crashed on Interstate 85. Officials said the other man was caught shortly after the crash, and Whitfield ended up at Parnell's doorstep.

Parnell's husband came home from a funeral and found her about 4:30 p.m., slumped over in the chair. Police say that after Mary Parnell went into cardiac arrest, Whitfield ran away and broke into another nearby home. He was arrested while walking in the neighborhood.

Parnell's autopsy report said she was overweight and diabetic, and she had an enlarged heart, kidney disease, hypertension, heart disease and advanced liver disease. Those factors were all found to be secondary. Dr. Steven Dunton, the deputy chief medical examiner in DeKalb County, Ga., said an autopsy finding of natural causes can be changed by what he calls an "external environmental factor."

In Parnell's case, doctors listed her cause of death as a heart attack resulting from "stress during home invasion."

"There's nothing seen by the pathologist that would show a person died that way," Dunton said. "That's entirely from circumstantial information."

Legal experts said those circumstances will be crucial to winning a murder conviction. Prosecutors must show that Whitfield's actions inside Parnell's home caused her death, said Michael Tigar, a Duke University Law School professor.

"Jurors very often resent what they see as overcharging," Tigar said. "They resent lawyers who claim too much for their cases. In most cases, ... [lawyers have] stretched the analysis or theory in order to heighten punishment, and are often penalized by the jury."

Parnell's family -- four children, five grandchildren and her husband of 59 years, Herman -- support the decision to seek a murder conviction, said the family attorney, H. Monroe Whitesides.

Whitfield, he said, "breaks into the house that she occupied with her husband for 59 years, and he kidnaps her and moves her to another room, and she has a heart attack. And you think that this Whitfield character ... ought to be excused for that?"

(Associated Press news researcher Julie Reed contributed to this report.)

All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be published, broadcast or redistributed in any manner.

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service