Labor groups join immigration push

Two federations support overhaul

The New York TimesApril 14, 2009 

The nation's two major labor federations have agreed for the first time to join forces to support an overhaul of the immigration system, leaders of both organizations said Monday.

The accord could give President Barack Obama significant support among unions as he revisits the stormy issue in the midst of the recession.

John Sweeney, president of the AFL-CIO, and Joe T. Hansen, a leader of the rival Change to Win federation, will present the outlines of their new position today in Washington. In 2007, when Congress last considered comprehensive immigration legislation, the two groups could not agree on a common approach. That legislation failed.

The accord endorses legalizing the status of illegal immigrants already in the United States and opposes any large new program for employers to bring in temporary immigrant workers, officials of both federations said.

"The labor movement will work together to make sure that the White House as well as Congress understand that we speak about immigration reform with one voice," Sweeney said in a statement to The New York Times.

But while the compromise repaired one fissure in the coalition that has favored broad immigration legislation, it appeared to open another. An official from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce said Monday that the business community remained committed to a significant guest-worker program.

"If the unions think they're going to push a bill through without the support of the business community, they're crazy," said Randel Johnson, the chamber's vice president of labor, immigration and employee benefits. "There's only going to be one shot at immigration reform. As part of the trade-off for legalization, we need to expand the temporary worker program."

The common labor position is also unlikely to convince many opponents that an immigration overhaul would not harm American workers. When Obama administration officials said last week that the president intended to push Congress this year to take up an immigration bill that would include a path to legal status for the country's estimated 12 million illegal immigrants, opponents criticized the approach as an amnesty for lawbreakers.

"In our current economic crisis, Americans cannot afford to lose more jobs to illegal workers," said Rep. Steve King, an Iowa Republican who sits on the House Judiciary subcommittee on immigration. "American workers are depending on President Obama to protect their jobs from those in America illegally."

A new approach

The two labor federations have agreed in the past to proposals that would give legal status to illegal immigrants. But in 2007 the AFL-CIO parted ways with the service employees and several other unions when it did not support legislation put forth by the Bush administration because it contained provisions for an expanded guest-worker program.

In the new accord, the AFL-CIO and Change to Win have called for managing future immigration of workers through a national commission. The commission would determine how many permanent and temporary foreign workers should be admitted each year based on demand in American labor markets. Union officials are confident that the result would reduce worker immigration during times of high unemployment like the present.

Hansen, who is president of the United Food and Commercial Workers Union, said in an interview that the joint proposal was a "building block to go forward to get immigration reform up on the agenda in Congress" sometime this year.

Thousands of immigrant farm workers and other low-wage laborers come to the United States through seasonal guest-worker programs that are subject to numerical visa limits and have been criticized by employers as rigid and inefficient. Many unions oppose the programs because the immigrants are tied to one employer and cannot change jobs no matter how abusive the conditions, so union officials say they undercut conditions for American workers.

Advocates for immigrants said a unified labor movement could substantially bolster their position as they push for legislation to restructure the ailing immigration system.

"It shows how important the issue is to the representatives of American workers," said Frank Sharry, executive director of America's Voice, an advocate group.

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service