Cupcakes for grown-up tastes

Staff WriterJanuary 27, 2010 

  • "Vegan Cupcakes Take Over the World: 75 Dairy-Free Recipes for Cupcakes that Rule" by Isa Chandra Moskowitz and Terry Hope Romero. This is the cookbook that inspired Kelley Gill of Kelley G's Cupcakes.

    "Martha Stewart's Cupcakes: 175 Inspired Ideas for Everyone's Favorite Treat" by Martha Stewart Living Magazine. It's hard to beat Martha Stewart for reliable recipes.

    "Baked: New Frontiers in Baking" by Matt Lewis and Renato Poliafito. This cookbook from the owners of a Brooklyn bakery has some knockout recipes, include some that may inspire your cupcake creations.

    "Baking From My Home To Yours" by Dorie Greenspan. Sugarland owner Katrina Ryan recommends this book with these caveats: To adapt a cake recipe for cupcakes, increase the amount of baking powder by a third and substitute 2 tablespoons canola oil for 1/4 cup butter. If you like domed cupcakes rather than flat, preheat the oven to a temperature 25 degrees higher than the recipe calls for and then turn it down once the cupcakes are in the oven.

The cupcake craze has hit the Triangle, not only with stores devoted to cupcakes but also with online-only bakers who will deliver a dozen to your door.

With Valentine's Day approaching, we thought we would sacrifice our thighs for the greater good and critique cupcakes from nine such bakers.

If you want to buy a sweet treat for your sweetheart, you merely have to pick up the phone and order, or plan a Valentine's Day date, picking up the cupcakes in person.


Owner: Kim Hammer

Locations: at Helios Cafe, Raleigh, and online.

Contact: 395-8848,

Web site:

Cost: $3 each at Helios; $24-$36 a dozen online.

Valentine's flavors: Mexican Hot Chocolate, a chocolate cupcake made with cinnamon and chipotle chili covered with cayenne chili-chocolate ganache frosting

This is how Hammer describes the impetus for her cupcake business: "A mom wanting to have good local, natural and predominately organic baked goods for my kids." She started baking for her family and other families, and it eventually became a business.


Owner: Mike Taylor

Location: 431 W. Franklin St. Chapel Hill

Contact: 636-3090

Web site:

Hours: 11 a.m. - 9 p.m. Monday through Thursday and 11 a.m.-10 p.m. Friday and Saturday. Closed Sunday

Cost: $2.50 each or $27 a dozen. $14 for half dozen.

Taylor managed a similar store in Pittsburgh. With family in North Carolina, he decided to move and open a cupcake shop in Chapel Hill. Every day, he offers six cupcakes with either chocolate or vanilla cake and topped with chocolate or vanilla butter cream or chocolate ganache. There's also a vegan cupcake every day and several chefs' creations. Each day from 5:30 to 7:30 p.m., all pastries are half price.


Owner: Carrie Gephart and David Menestres

Location: Only online and phone orders

Contact: 413-8134,

Web site:

Cost: $4-$8 per cupcake

Valentine's flavors: Miso Horny is chocolate stout cake, miso caramel filling and ganache and caramel topping.

Cupcakes are a small part of the baking business that Gephart formed with musician Menestres in October. Gephart worked at Raleigh's Hayes Barton Cafe & Dessertery for years. The pair also makes cakes, pies, tarts and cookies. They focused on cupcakes for the Shotbox espresso shop that was open during the holiday market at Designbox in downtown Raleigh. Their cupcakes often involve alcohol, from the frosting to the cake, because, they say, "Who doesn't love alcohol?"

Tasting Notes: We loved the names of the cupcakes, from one with jalapeno-tinged frosting called Slow Burn to a White Russian cupcake called Little Lebowski Urban Achievers. The unique flavor additions of these cupcakes, whether tequila or jalapeno, always seem to hit you on the end of your palate. If you like that sensation, you will love these cupcakes.

The Cupcake Bar

Owner: Anna Branly and Katie Braam

Locations: Online, and 3-5 p.m. Feb. 13 at Super Suppers, 1817 N Harrison Ave., Cary.

Contact:, 816-2905

Web site:

Cost: $24 to $30 a dozen, or $1.25-$2.75 for single cupcakes at the Feb. 13 event.

Valentine's flavors: Four chocolate cupcakes with vanilla butter cream with dark and white chocolate XOXO decorations for $12 plus tax and delivery fee, or available for pickup at Singles Night if ordered by Feb. 11.

Sisters Branly and Braam gave up careers in marketing and social work to follow their cupcake dream in 2008. They make regular cupcakes from chocolate to lemon or red velvet, and they make cocktail-inspired cupcakes. Their margarita cupcake is orange cake with lime frosting, and a mojito cupcake is a lime rum cake with mint butter cream. Once a month, they offer a Singles Night at Super Suppers in Cary, where they rent kitchen space so people can taste a cupcake or two without having to purchase a whole dozen.

Cupcake Envy

Owner: Amy Eilert

Location: Available online only.

Contact: 453-0779

Web site:

Cost: $25 for cakelets made for one. Cupcakes cost $3.

Valentine's flavors: Heart-shaped cakelets, as well as an anti-Valentine's Day voodoo doll cakelet that has been very popular.

Eilert focuses on making "cakelets," decorated cakes that fit into the palm of your hand. Typically, the guest of honor will receive a cakelet in the shape of a dress, purse or hockey puck and the other guests receive cupcakes. Recently, her cakelets in the shape of dresses were featured on the season premiere of "Ugly Betty." Eilert also teaches hands-on cupcake classes, with one on Friday and another set for Feb. 5.

The Cupcake Shoppe

Owner: Sara Coleman

Location: 104 Glenwood Ave., Raleigh

Contact: 821-4223

Web site:

Hours: 10 a.m.-8 p.m. Tuesday through Thursday, 10 a.m.-11 p.m. Friday-Saturday.

Cost: $3 each or $33 a dozen. Mini-cupcakes are $16 for a dozen.

Valentine's flavors: Champagne Strawberry, strawberry cake with champagne butter cream; Chocolate Truffle, dark chocolate cake and butter cream rolled in chocolate sprinkles.

After four moves in six yeas as a saleswoman with Johnson & Johnson, Coleman was ready to return to Raleigh. (She graduated from N.C. State University.) Baking had always been a love of hers, and she had often helped her aunt with a catering business. So Coleman decided to open a small bakery with a focus on cupcakes. Cupcake Shoppe was the first cupcake-centered bakery to open in Raleigh. Beyond being a cupcake cafe that serves Larry's Beans coffee and other beverages, it also offers custom cakes for birthdays, baby showers, weddings and corporate events.

Tasting Notes: We would describe these cupcakes as "sugar bombs." They are equal amounts dense cake and butter cream frosting, so these are for those who really like frosting.

Daisy Cakes

Owner: Tanya Catolos

Location: Online, and 9 a.m.-noon. Saturdays at Foster and Geer streets in downtown Durham.

Contact:, 389-4307

Web site:

Cost: $2.50 each

Valentine's flavors: Chocolate Raspberry.

Catolos is a pastry chef at the Washington Duke Inn. She wanted to open her own bakery but realized opening a storefront was too expensive. So she and her husband bought an Airstream trailer and park near the Durham Farmers Market each Saturday to sell pastries. Beyond cupcakes, they sell bread pudding, a treat called a Pop't-Art - a warm pastry filled with fruit preserves and served warm - and Counter Culture coffee. Some recent cupcakes included ginger stout with cream cheese frosting and chocolate with peppermint butter cream.

Tasting Notes: We adored the chocolate cake used to make the black and white cupcake. It was so dense that it was brownie-like. We also discovered that these cupcakes require the perfect bite: a bit of frosting and a bit of cake. With both, your cupcake eating experience is better than just tasting one or the other.

Kelley G's Cupcakes

Owner: Kelley Gill

Locations: Open Eye Cafe and Looking Glass Cafe, both in Carrboro; Caffe Driade in Chapel Hill

Contact: 923-0956 or

Web site:

Cost: $24-$29 a dozen. $5 delivery fee for outside Chapel Hill/Carrboro

Valentine's flavors: Red Velvet and Chocolate Raspberry

Gill took a year off from studying for a master's degree in philosophy from Washington University in St. Louis and moved to Carrboro. She bought a copy of "Vegan Cupcakes Take Over The World," by Isa Chandra Moskowitz and Terry Hope Romero. She took a dozen vegan cupcakes to a potluck and people loved them so much that they placed orders. Then some of the local cafes started carrying them. Gill will deliver a dozen to your door or bake cupcakes for your wedding. She also offers gluten-free and sugar-free varieties.


Owner: Katrina Ryan

Location: 140 E. Franklin St. Chapel Hill

Contact: 929-2100

Web site:

Hours: 10 a.m. to 10 p.m. Monday through Thursday, 9 a.m.-midnight Friday and Saturday, 9 a.m. to 10 p.m. Sunday.

Cost: $3.25 each or $33 a dozen.

Valentine's flavors: Candy heart cupcakes with custom messages on fondant hearts. You must order them ahead.

The myth of Sugarland is that Ryan always wanted to open a bakery. Actually, the former pastry chef at La Residence restaurant in Chapel Hill says she always wanted to open a restaurant but her husband kept spreading the bakery rumor. So town boosters approached the couple about opening a bakery in the space formerly occupied by Julian's clothing shop. The location was so good they couldn't pass up the opportunity. They didn't sell cupcakes at first, but customer demand drove them to offer up to 10 different cupcakes a day. Ryan said Monday is always an interesting cupcake day because they use the ingredients left over from the weekend's wedding cake orders to make the cupcakes. They also sell gelato in 24 flavors and have a full bar.

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service