Editorials

Now on Twitter: Follow the N&O editorial department at @NOopinionshop

Published Fri, Mar 19, 2010 02:00 AM
Modified Fri, Mar 19, 2010 06:09 AM

... deemed unnecessary

Email Print Order Reprint
Share This
Text

tool name

close x
tool goes here
Tags: news | opinion - editorial | staff editorial

The can smell it. They can taste it. They, being the Capitol Hill Democrats who are attempting to jockey health care reform down the home stretch to passage. What a monumental achievement it would be, and the nation will be a better place if they succeed.

A Republican phalanx, however, stands firm in trying to block the reform legislation and deny victory to the Democrats and President Obama. Enough Democrats feel vulnerable to the Republicans' barbs that their leaders are taking extraordinary steps to give them cover.

Already, because their Senate majority is one vote short of what's needed to stop a GOP filibuster, the Democrats are resorting to an arcane "reconciliation" maneuver to make changes in the main bill without bringing the bill to another Senate vote.

But there's another strategy in the works on the House side that makes reconciliation look as straightforward as falling off a log. The idea would be to let the reform bill be "deemed" to have passed - without members actually having to vote for it.

OK, it might work, in terms of pushing the legislation across the finish line.

But the question has to be - would this maneuver really fool anyone? Of course not. A vote to proceed with the "deem and pass" rule would simply translate into a vote for health care reform. Whatever slings and arrows were to be aimed at a House member for supporting reform directly would just as surely be aimed at the person for supporting reform indirectly. The upshot would be the same.

This could become an instance of Democratic leaders being too clever for their own good. They'd open themselves to further criticism for using a dubious procedure, one that might well face a legal challenge. Better to call upon their skittish colleagues to stand and do the right thing at a critical moment in the nation's history.

Get the biggest news in your email or cellphone as it's happening. Sign up for breaking news alerts.

Email Print Order Reprint
Share This
Text

tool name

close x
tool goes here
We welcome your comments on this story, but please be civil. Do not use profanity, hate speech, threats, personal abuse, images, internet links or any device to draw undue attention. Read our full comment policy.
More Editorials

Get editorial updates

Keep up with the latest opinions from the News & Observer, delivered straight to your inbox, for free!

- it's free!

Hot Deals View All
Find a Car
Go
Top Jobs View All

Find a Job
Go
Featured Homes View All
Find a Home
Go

Print Ads