Video shames Etheridge, galvanizes Republicans

The Lillington Democrat apologizes profusely for his reaction to interviewers who remain anonymous.

Staff WritersJune 15, 2010 

  • The video opens with U.S. Rep. Bob Etheridge walking up a sidewalk toward the camera.

    Man 1: Hi, Congressman!

    Etheridge: How are you?

    Man 1: How are you?

    (Etheridge walks by)

    Message on screen: What happens when a U.S. Representative meets a college kid on the street in Washington?

    Man 1: (holds small camera a few inches from Etheridge's face) Do you ...

    Etheridge: Who are you?

    Man 1: ... fully support the Obama agenda?

    Etheridge: Who are you? Who are you? Who are you? (Video shows Etheridge's face filling the frame)

    The video camera gets knocked away and Etheridge grabs the man by his wrist.

    Man 1: Whoa.

    Message on screen: He goes BESERK!

    Video shows the same scene again, from a second angle:

    Etheridge: (Grabs first man by his right wrist.) Who are you? Who are you?

    Man 1: I'm just here for a project, sir.

    Etheridge: Tell me who you are.

    Man 2: We're just here for a project sir.

    Etheridge (Still holding first man's wrist) Tell me who you are.

    Man 2: We're just here for a project.

    Etheridge: I don't care about ...

    Man 1: Sir, will you please let go of my hand?

    Etheridge: Tell me who you are.

    Man 1: I'm just a student, sir.

    Etheridge: From?


    Man 2: We're just students. That's all we are.

    Etheridge: I have a right to know who you are if you're ...

    Man 2: We're just students.

    Man 1: We're in the public way.

    Etheridge: So am I. Who are you?

    (no answer)

    Etheridge: Who are you?

    Man 1: Please let go of my arm, sir.

    Man 2: Sir.

    Etheridge: (Lets go of the man's arm, then grabs him by the back of the neck and pulls him around next to him.) Who are you?

    Man 2: Sir! Sir! Sir! Please ...

    Man 1: Congressman, please let go of me.

    Etheridge: (Lets go.) Who are you?

    Man 1: OK ...

    Etheridge turns and walks off.

  • Democratic Rep. Bob Etheridge, 68, has represented North Carolina's 2nd Congressional District since 1996. After a career as a farmer, hardware store owner and radio station owner, Etheridge served on the Harnett County Board of Commissioners, then in the state House and then as North Carolina's superintendent of public instruction.

    Etheridge usually wins in congressional races by large margins - 67 percent in 2008, 67 percent in 2006, 62 percent in 2004. But public opinion polls suggested that Etheridge's vote for the Democratic health care bill last year was unpopular in his district and that he faced a more difficult re-election effort than usual even before the most recent incident.

    Renee Ellmers, a 46-year-old nurse from Dunn who became active in politics last year because of her opposition to the Democratic health care bill, is making her first run for political office.

    She won the Republican primary in May, winning 55percent over two opponents. Ellmers has put together an experienced team of Republican political consultants.

    Her husband, Brent Ellmers, is a general surgeon, and the couple run a practice and a wound clinic.

  • Other unflattering political videos in recent years:

    August 2006: Republican Sen. George Allen of Virginia is filmed using the term "macaca" about an operative for his opponent, Democrat James Webb. Allen lost his seat.

    July 2007: Footage of presidential candidate John Edwards, waiting for a television interview and fixing his hair, is set to the song "I Feel Pretty." It didn't help his reputation.

    May 2008: Then-candidate Barack Obama is taped at a fundraiser saying that rural voters cling to God and guns because they are bitter. The comment fuels criticism during the campaign that Obama is an elitist and out of touch with Americans.

    October 2008: Footage of then-candidate Kay Hagan attending a fundraiser hosted by an atheist group is used in a campaign ad by her Republican opponent, then-Sen. Elizabeth Dole. The ad is criticized as being unfair and overreaching. Dole lost the campaign.

    July 2009: A video of two activists posing as a pimp and a prostitute who are seeking help from ACORN in setting up a brothel creates a backlash against the group.

    May 2010: A rabbi outside the Jewish Heritage Celebration Day Event at the White House films Hearst columnist Helen Thomas saying that the Jews should get out of Palestine and go to Germany and Poland. Thomas retired after the video caused an uproar.

    June 2010: N.C. Republicans, hoping to raise money, spread a video showing the Forsyth County Republican Party chairman, Nathan Tabor, in a scuffle with a man at a Tea Party protest. Both men have been charged with simple assault.

The video was harsh. There was U.S. Rep. Bob Etheridge, a grandfather with a nice-guy reputation, fuming on a Washington sidewalk. He grabbed the wrist of a young man - then the scruff of the man's neck - all the while demanding: "Who are you? Who are you?"

The Internet video immediately dominated cable television Monday, highlighting a growing trend in political discourse: bloggers and students catching politicians off guard, recording unflattering moments, then blasting them across the Internet.

By day's end, Etheridge, a Lillington Democrat, had apologized, saying he "deeply and profoundly" regretted how he reacted. And his until-now-unknown opponent, Renee Ellmers of Dunn, acknowledged that the minute-long clip could play quite nicely in a fall campaign commercial.

"We live in a different world. There are no unguarded moments," said Gary Pearce, a former Democratic campaign consultant for Jim Hunt, John Edwards and Terry Sanford. "Any exchange you have with somebody, any flash of temper, any stupid thing you say or do is liable to be seen by thousands and thousands of people in a matter of hours."

The video was first posted at sites affiliated with conservative commentator and publisher Andrew Breitbart, who runs a burgeoning empire of websites that aggregate, and sometimes make, news. Breitbart told The Associated Press that the men who shot the video did not work for him and did not get paid.

It's unclear who made the video. It was posted anonymously, with the face of one of the two men blurred to prevent identification. The second man never appears on the video; his voice is heard from behind the camera.

As the video was highlighted repeatedly on cable news networks Monday, Etheridge called a news conference in Raleigh to apologize.

"It's obvious I wasn't thinking as straight as I should have thought," Etheridge said in an interview. "There's no excuse for it."

'Etheridge has lost it'

The video shows Etheridge walking from a Democratic dinner featuring Speaker Nancy Pelosi on June 9. (Etheridge said he does not drink alcohol and said he hadn't been drinking at the event.)

One of the men greets Etheridge, then holds a small camera inches from his face.

"Do you fully support the Obama agenda?" he asks.

Etheridge demands to know who the men are, then grabs the wrist of the first. He holds on for several seconds as the man repeatedly asks him to let go. Etheridge then snags him by the back of the neck and pulls him into an awkward clinch.

The men reply that they are college students working on a project, but they don't say where they study or give further information.

Etheridge was roundly criticized for his actions.

"Bob Etheridge has lost it. His conduct is unbecoming of a member of Congress," Jon Thompson, a spokesman for the National Republican Congressional Committee, said in a statement.

Tom Fetzer, chairman of the N.C. GOP, said Etheridge had a choice and "could have just walked on by."

"I guarantee you Bobby Etheridge's mother did not raise him to behave that way," Fetzer said.

Ellmers' fortunes rise

Many bloggers encouraged readers to support Ellmers, Etheridge's Republican opponent.

By Monday afternoon, she had a fresh injection of cash from hundreds of supporters in California, Wisconsin, Georgia and other far-flung states. She did not say how much.

"I think this does put a whole different spectrum to who he is," said Ellmers, a nurse. "I'm not going to try to take advantage of it. It's a terrible situation. I feel badly for him."

After Etheridge's apology, White House press secretary Robert Gibbs, who worked for Etheridge in Congress, called him "one of the most honorable people I know."

"Everyone makes mistakes, and I'm proud of Bob for taking responsibility and apologizing for this," Gibbs said.

Anyone can carry a camera

Andy Taylor, chairman of the political science department at N.C. State University, said many people now have a video camera in their pocket. With a quick clip, they can influence the public discourse.

"These people don't need to be professional reporters, and they don't need access to mainstream media or direct access to mainstream media," Taylor said.

Traditionally, mainstream reporters covering beats have been setting the agenda, Taylor said. But now, anyone can do it.

Videos used as political weapons have been increasing since the infamous moment in August 2006 when Republican Sen. George Allen of Virginia was filmed calling a supporter of his opponent a "macaca" - an ethnic slur - during a campaign rally. Allen lost his re-election bid.

In the past year, two young conservatives videotaped staffers at the ACORN community organization appearing to suggest criminal actions to potential clients dressed as a prostitute and a pimp.

And a few weeks ago, the liberal blog Think Progress posted a video of U.S. Sen. Richard Burr and other Republicans walking into a fundraiser with the financial affairs lobby.

Burr, of Winston-Salem, didn't engage the videographers; he smiled and walked away.

'Partisan journalism'

"I think as you see more and more of these type of blogs, you see more and more of this kind of partisan journalism," said Brad Woodhouse, spokesman for the Democratic National Committee and a former employee in Etheridge's office.

Woodhouse said he suspects the Etheridge video was taken by Republican trackers - low-level campaign workers who routinely film opponents' actions - who didn't expect Etheridge to turn combative. Woodhouse pointed out that bloggers usually take credit for their work.

"It's important for the mainstream press to ask: What were their motives?" Woodhouse said.

Both the Republican National Committee and the National Republican Congressional Committee said they had nothing to do with the video.

No twisting of the knife

Etheridge said he's trying to put the incident behind him.

But Ellmers, his opponent, appeared at a news conference Monday afternoon with state Republican party officials. She is so new to politics that a GOP news release on the event initially misspelled her name.

The National Republican Congressional Committee, which seeks out good local candidates, was in touch Monday with her campaign staff.

Ellmers said she wants the campaign to focus on Etheridge's voting record and not on this gaffe. "I hate to stick the dagger in deeper," she said.

But, she added, the video is out there now and cannot be ignored.

By day's end, Fetzer had sent an e-mail message to Republican supporters offering them a choice: Etheridge or Ellmers?

The e-mail included a link to raise money for Ellmers' campaign. or 202-383-0012

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service