Fowler: St. Pierre 'unforgettable' in loss

Staff columnistNovember 21, 2010 

— For three quarters Sunday, new Carolina quarterback Brian St. Pierre did so little in the Panthers’ game against Baltimore that you almost forgot he was there.

In the fourth quarter, he became unforgettable. St. Pierre threw three touchdown passes in the final 15 minutes of Carolina’s 37-13 loss to Baltimore – but two of them went to the guys in the other uniforms in the space of 11 shocking seconds.

And so it came to pass that we all came to understand why St. Pierre – who in his seventh NFL season, at age 30, was making his first NFL start – had not started a game any sooner than this.

St. Pierre seems like a great guy. He’s just not a very good quarterback. “I didn’t want to let anyone down,” St. Pierre said later, “especially on my team. I didn’t want to be the reason we lost. Unfortunately, I was definitely part of it.”

St. Pierre has the attitude you want. He actually believed Carolina (1-9) could win this game, and for a few seconds in the fourth quarter it looked like he might be right.

In the first three quarters, St. Pierre threw one short, safe, ultimately unsuccessful pass after another. It was as if the Panthers had banned him from throwing the ball more than five yards. He threw for 51 yards in those three quarters – a number so paltry that CBS aired a graphic showing that St. Pierre had a chance to throw for the fewest yards all season by an NFL starter.

But then came St. Pierre’s one great moment – an 88-yard touchdown pass to David Gettis that was as pretty as the sunny fall afternoon. Gettis blew by the cornerback guarding him, safety Ed Reed cheated toward Steve Smith and St. Pierre – whose arm strength has always been questionable – threw a perfect deep ball.

Suddenly, Carolina only trailed 20-13 and there were still 14-plus minutes to go. St. Pierre, who came into the game having thrown for only 12 yards in his entire NFL career, had just gotten more than seven times that yardage on a single play.

Growled Baltimore linebacker Terrell Suggs: “At that point we said, ‘That’s enough. We’ve let them play around long enough.’”

The Panthers got the ball back once down by seven, but did nothing. St. Pierre threw another three-yard pass on third-and-five.

Then Baltimore kicked a field goal, making it 23-13, and the onslaught began. On third-and-11, St. Pierre tried to fit a 15-yard pass into Dante Rosario in tight coverage. Baltimore’s Ed Reed easily intercepted it and lateraled to Dawan Landry, who scored.

On Carolina’s next offensive play, St. Pierre saw a Baltimore blitz, threw to his “hot” read – and saw Ray Lewis pick it off and run 24 yards for a touchdown.

“I have a lot of pride in doing my job and doing my job right,” St. Pierre said. “I wished I did it a little better today.”

Nevertheless, St. Pierre (13-for-28, 173 yards, 1 TD, two interceptions) could have been worse Sunday. “I thought he did really well for the game relatively speaking,” Panther coach John Fox said. “Even the way it ended up, a couple of those were not all to blame on the quarterback.”

“I thought he played pretty good,” wide receiver Steve Smith said. “I mean, he just rolled out of bed and threw an 80-yard bomb.”

“To come in and understand the offense well enough to run a full game plan against an outstanding defense – that’s big,” offensive tackle Jordan Gross said.

St. Pierre’s wife, parents and two brothers came to the game to see his first NFL start. It might be his last, but I bet he starts at least one more game for the Panthers this season, too. Carolina will be careful with Clausen’s head injury, and St. Pierre did play well enough Sunday to secure the No.2 role for the rest of 2010.

Beyond that? St. Pierre doesn’t know. “I’m just hopefully going to try to find a place to live other than the hotel this week,” he said.

St. Pierre reminds me a little of Jake Delhomme. He is a stand-up guy who adapts well. He is naturally self-deprecating – not many NFL players would have admitted they were changing a diaper when they got the call less than two weeks ago to join the Panthers.

However, St. Pierre doesn’t have – and none of the Panthers’ other quarterbacks have yet shown – Delhomme’s ability to win games regularly in the clutch. Delhomme threw some terrible interceptions just like St. Pierre did Sunday, but he counter-balanced those with a bushel of fourth-quarter comebacks.

Carolina has yet to find Delhomme’s permanent replacement. Maybe it will be Jimmy Clausen -- who will re-assume the starting job once he recovers from a concussion.

Maybe it’s Tony Pike or Armanti Edwards – although not under Fox, as the coach stiffed both rookies in favor of St. Pierre Sunday. Maybe it’s someone else not yet on the roster.

But it’s not St. Pierre.

sfowler@charlotteobserver.com or 704-358-5140

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service