Duke-Progress hearings to cover job losses

Proceedings begin today in the Duke Energy-Progress Energy merger.

Staff WriterSeptember 20, 2011 

  • The N.C. Utilities Commission is an independent agency. Members are appointed by the governor for eight-year terms and are paid $123,198 a year. The commission chairman is paid $137,203 a year.

    Edward S. Finley Jr., chairman

    Appointed by Gov. Mike Easley in 2007; reappointed by Gov. Bev Perdue in July. Finley was a lawyer in private practice for 33 years and specialized in utility regulation.

    Lorinzo Little Joyner

    Appointed by Gov. Mike Easley in 2001; reappointed by Gov. Bev Perdue in 2009. Joyner worked for 20 years as a government lawyer.

    William Thomas Culpepper III

    Appointed by Gov. Mike Easley in 2006. He was a Chowan County attorney from 1979 to 2005, and a member the N.C. House from 1993 to 2005.

    Bryan E. Beatty

    Appointed by Gov. Mike Easley in 2009; reappointed by Gov. Bev Perdue the same year. He was the Secretary of the N.C. Department of Crime Control and Public Safety from 2001 until 2009, and directed the State Bureau of Investigation from October 1999 to January 2001.

    Susan Warren Rabon

    Appointed by Gov. Mike Easley in 2009. She joined the N.C. Attorney General's Office in 1993; in 2001, she became one of Easley's top three advisers.

    ToNola D. Brown-Bland

    Appointed by Gov. Bev Perdue in 2009. A former staff attorney at the N.C. Utilities Commission. From 2005 until her appointment, she was associate general counsel with the City of Greensboro.

    Lucy T. Allen

    Appointed by Gov. Bev Perdue in 2010. A former middle school language arts teacher, she served eight years on the Franklin County Board of Education, and then as mayor of Louisburg for 16 years. She was elected to the N.C. House in 2002 for the first of four terms.

    Source: N.C. Utilities Commission

  • What: Public hearings on the Duke-Progress merger.

    When: 9 a.m. today.

    Where: Dobbs Building, 430 N. Salisbury St., Raleigh.

    Room: Commission Hearing Room 2115

    The N.C. Utilities Commission begins public hearings today on the proposed merger between Duke Energy and Progress Energy. The hearings could last the entire week as commissioners hear from a parade of witnesses and experts.

    Today, the hearing room is expected to be standing-room-only as residents line up to speak during the first portion of the proceedings. Duke CEO Jim Rogers and Progress CEO Bill Johnson will make their case for the merger after citizens have their say.

The proposed merger between Duke Energy and Progress Energy just got more interesting.

State regulators who begin public hearings on the merger this morning have agreed to review the broad social costs of the $26 billion deal, including possible remedies for the hundreds of job losses the merger will bring.

The state's two biggest electric companies had argued that such concerns were out of bounds in a merger proceeding and should not be allowed for debate. The utilities plan to combine into the nation's largest electric utility, with 7.1 million customers in six states, and say it will result in greater financial stability and leaner operations.

Critics countered that it would be reckless not to consider the long-term consequences of the 2,000 job cuts the companies plan as part of their consolidation. North Carolina's jobless rate is above the national average, and the state's economy is still sputtering more than a year after the recession ended.

"This is too big of a decision, too big of an issue," said Stephen Smith, director of the Southern Alliance for Clean Energy, one of the groups challenging the merger. "When you couple the significant job loss with questionable benefit numbers, that's why you need a public hearing. Are there other potential downsides that haven't been accounted for?"

State law requires the N.C. Utilities Commission to review utility mergers and to make sure the public benefits outweigh the costs and risks.

The merger is widely expected to be approved, but the N.C. Utilities Commission has broad powers to impose conditions that could require the companies to hold down rates, contribute money to social programs, and promise greater strides in clean energy and pollution reductions.

The merger hearings, which could last all week in Raleigh, take place in the wake of last week's news that the state's jobless rate in August was 10.4 percent, the highest unemployment level in more than a year.

The merger also requires approval from the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, which could require the sell-off of transmission systems and power plants if the merger is found to create a monopoly. But the review in North Carolina could have greater impact on the final terms of the merger because both companies are based in the state and the economic repercussions of the merger will play out here for decades.

'A broad perspective'

The corporate marriage will mean the loss of a Fortune 500 corporate headquarters in Raleigh after the company is consolidated in Charlotte. Progress plans to eliminate as many as 1,000 jobs - half its downtown Raleigh workforce. Duke has yet to say how many cuts could come in the Charlotte area.

Still, Duke and Progress had urged the commissioners to restrict the scope of the hearings to consider only the merger's impact on customer rates, not other consequences.

"The commission is taking a broad perspective in assessing the costs and benefits of the proposed merger," Progress spokesman Mike Hughes said. "That is certainly the commission's prerogative."

The merger's costs have not been quantified. Duke and Progress plan to spend hundreds of millions of dollars on severance payments to employees who are laid off and those who take voluntary buyouts. The companies then plan to ask the commission to make customers pay for those payments in their monthly utility bills. The state's consumer advocate, the Public Staff, has vowed to fight that request whenever it's made.

A number of nonprofit advocacy organizations contend the merger's sweeping job cuts will require substantial compensation to offset the damage to the state's depressed economy. The critics suggest an increase in green energy and conservation programs to help create jobs. N.C. Waste Awareness and Reduction Network, based in Durham, wants the merged utility to contribute $270 million to low-income housing assistance programs for weatherization and other services.

The companies have guaranteed that the net savings from combined fuel contracts and power plant operations will be $650 million over five years. Those savings will benefit customers, executives say, by reducing the overall impact of rate increases.

"We believe the benefits of the merger are compelling for customers," Hughes said. "The merged company will be better positioned than the companies individually to invest billions of dollars needed to build new plants and power systems in the coming years while ensuring reliability and lower overall cost for customers."

john.murawski@newsobserver.com or 919-829-8932

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service