Before hoops madness defined the month of March, basketball fans in North Carolina reserved their tournament fervor for December, when the Dixie Classic enlivened Reynolds Coliseum and made Raleigh into the holiday destination of sports fans across the state.
The tournament, the brainchild of N.C. State head coach Everett Case and former News & Observer sports editor Dick Herbert, was staged for the first time just weeks after Reynolds Coliseum opened in 1949 and shut down in 1961 after local players were implicated in a nationwide point-shaving scandal.
Each of the 12 Dixie Classics featured the Big Four – N.C. State, North Carolina, Wake Forest and Duke – playing against four visiting teams invited by Case. And even though top-ranked outsiders came year after year to compete, no team from outside North Carolina ever won the Classic trophy.
Talk to any ACC basketball fan over the age of 65, and the odds are good that they once received Dixie Classic tickets in their Christmas stocking. For former Raleigh mayor and Wolfpack basketball player Smedes York, the tickets were a better incentive than Santa Claus.
“My dad would get the tickets, and he would put them in our stockings,” York said. “If we were not behaving, he would say, ‘You’re not going to get those Dixie Classic tickets.’”
Former Governor Jim Hunt was in a quandary on the final day of the three-day tournament in 1958. His wife Carolyn was in labor with their first child, and Hunt had Dixie Classic tickets. He made sure Carolyn was OK, dashed over to Reynolds and watched a full slate of basketball. When the games were over, Hunt drove back to Rex just in time for his daughter’s birth.
“The quality of the teams and the play was of the highest order,” Hunt said. “The excitement and the cheering of the fans and getting into the spirit of it was as great as any event I’ve ever attended of any kind.”
Former Dixie Classic players, including Raleigh’s Jack Murdock (WFU) and Lou Pucillo (NCSU), agree that at the height of the tournament they would rather have returned to campus with a Classic trophy than one from the ACC Tournament. Pucillo was one of the stars of the Wolfpack’s greatest Dixie Classic title in 1958, when they toppled powerhouses like Michigan State and top-ranked Cincinnati.
After watching the Wolfpack beat Michigan State in that memorable 1958 final, Louisville coach Peck Hickman realized that he had just witnessed something extraordinary. “They just about played the perfect basketball game,” Hickman said of N.C. State.
N.C. State relished the role of the Dixie Classic home team, and the Wolfpack dominance was absolute in the tournament’s early years. They would win three more, with Wake and Duke taking one each and UNC prevailing in three. No one would have predicted that the dramatic 1958 victory would be the Wolfpack’s last Dixie Classic or that less than three years later the tournament would be gone.
To this day, prominent Triangle sports figures like Bucky Waters are quick to register their disagreement with the decision – made by former UNC system president Bill Friday – to cancel the tournament as a response to the point-shaving scandal and the threats that were reportedly made to players who didn’t keep the score within the agreed-upon spread. But Friday believed that the scandal highlighted the overemphasis of college athletics, and that by canceling the Dixie Classic he could curb that excess.
“The Dixie Classic, in a way, was a forerunner of what’s going on in American sports today,” Friday said. “The NCAA is getting more serious about their sanctions, but the tragedy of it is that we have to do it at all, because we aren’t here to run an entertainment business, we’re here to run a good university.”
For Classic fans like former Wake coach Dave Odom, who was a boy during the Dixie Classic heyday, the memories endure.
“It was the greatest three days,” Odom said. “You saw four games a day for three days, and you saw the best teams in the country, the best players in the country … playing before the best fans in the country. It was easily the most respected and longed-for holiday tournament in the country, even to this day.”
Bethany Bradsher is the author of “The Classic: How Everett Case and His Tournament Brought Big-Time Basketball to the South.” For more information, visit www.thedixieclassic.com.