From the Editor

Drescher: Parts of outdoors column were plagiarized

jdrescher@newsobserver.comNovember 17, 2012 

In his farewell column in Thursday’s News & Observer, longtime outdoors correspondent Bob Simpson apologized for recently using material from another writer without giving credit.

Simpson’s Nov. 1 column was similar in many ways to an essay published by humorist Patrick F. McManus. The essay was part of a collection of McManus’ work published in several books. Simpson and McManus know each other and over the years have written for some of the same outdoors publications.

The structure of the essays was similar, as was the wording in several places. For example, McManus wrote: “My research paper, ‘Levitation: A Roommate’s Response to a Garter Snake in His Bed,’ caught the fancy of a psychology professor who invited me to join him in research on abnormal behavior in lesser primates.”

In his Nov. 1 column, Simpson described research from his college years. He wrote: “One excellent example was in submitting a research paper titled, ‘Levitation: a Roommate’s response to Black Snake in his Bed.’ This caught the attention of the psychology department, which invited a couple of the more notable students to participate in ‘abnormal behavior in lesser primates....’”

When a reader pointed out the similarities in the two pieces of writing, we asked Simpson about them. He acknowledged borrowing heavily from the McManus piece without giving credit and apologized.

We agreed mutually that Simpson should stop writing the column. Simpson, 87, is not a member of the staff but has been a correspondent for The N&O since the 1950s. Recent health problems have made it difficult for him to get outdoors. That has limited his ability to write his column.

Simpson was admitted to the hospital recently with pneumonia. He was released and is at his home at the coast.

“While it’s been more fun for me than I can describe, it’s time to hang it up,” Simpson wrote in his farewell column.

Simpson said the Nov. 1 column was the only one in which he borrowed material from another writer and did not give credit. We randomly selected four recent columns and ran them through two computer programs that detect plagiarism. The programs can detect word-for-word copying but are less successful when sentences have been rewritten.

There was no indication that any of the other Simpson columns were copied from another writer.

Simpson has been a spirited observer and graceful writer for The N&O for more than five decades. We wish him well.

It’s college basketball time

College basketball season has begun. If you want to dribble down the (memory) lane, check out our Photo Store at newsobserver.com.

Columnist Caulton Tudor and Scott Sharpe, director of photography, have combed through 60 years of N&O archives and found some of the best ACC men’s basketball photos ever.

We will be adding vintage photos to the Photo Store as the season unfolds. Prints are available for sale online.

For another trip into the era of cigarette-clouded arenas and short shorts, see our special section in Thursday’s N&O. It commemorates the 30th anniversary of N.C. State’s march to the NCAA championship, led by Jim Valvano.

Around here – the college basketball capital of the country – the chilly weather foreshadows the beginning of our regional passion.

With three ranked teams in the Triangle for the first time in years, this is going to be a great season.

Drescher: 919-829-4515 or jdrescher@newsobserver.com. On Twitter @john_drescher

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service