US Airways, American merger talks still up in the air

Analysts say reduced competition wouldn’t be good for travelers

Los Angeles TimesDecember 17, 2012 


An American Airlines Inc. McDonnell Douglas MD-82 plane sits parked at a gate while a United Continental Holdings plane taxis down the runway at LaGuardia Airport in the Queens borough of New York, U.S., on Wednesday, Nov. 21, 2012. U.S. travel during the Thanksgiving holiday weekend will rise a fourth straight year, gaining 0.7 percent from 2011, as trips by automobile rise even as airplane trips decline, AAA said last week. Photographer: Michael Nagle/Bloomberg

MICHAEL NAGLE — 2012 Bloomberg File Photo

A global recession and a surge in fuel prices sparked a frenzy of airline mergers and acquisitions in the past decade, as carriers joined forces to stay airborne amid economic turbulence.

Merger mania is not over. The biggest yet may be in the works, combining American Airlines and US Airways into the nation’s largest airline with up to 1,500 planes in its main line and regional fleets and more than 120,000 employees.

Analysts say a merger between Fort Worth, Texas-based American and Tempe, Ariz.-based US Airways could be announced as soon as January. It would produce a mega-airline with an estimated value of about $8 billion.

Airline experts debated the financial merits of a merger, but they agreed passengers could face some short-term headaches if a deal happens.

“Mergers are never good for passengers because there are always disruptions,” said Joe Brancatelli, an airline expert and online columnist on business travel.

If merger history is any guide, the integration of American and US Airways could lead to reservation-system glitches, labor disputes and a cut in services to some markets, experts say. Airline mergers, they add, mean fewer competitors and thus higher fares.

“I believe merging the two companies would be at least a two-year difficult period with many challenges,” said Ray Neidl, an airline analyst for Maxim Group, a New York investment banking firm.

Executives of the parent companies of US Airways and American Airlines are meeting privately and declined to comment publicly on a potential merger. But the union for American Airlines pilots, which supports a merger, says an integrated American-US Airways would fly more efficiently and offer more destinations.

Still, Tom Hoban, spokesman for the Allied Pilots Association, concedes that “there are always going to be some operational challenges.”

Indeed, airline mergers rarely run smoothly.

Dozens of United Airlines flights have been delayed over the past year because of computer glitches, apparently resulting from efforts to switch over to the reservation system formerly used by merger partner Continental.

Integrating labor groups, such as pilots, can also lead to problems, such as strikes and job actions.

US Airways completed a merger with America West Airlines in 2005 but has yet to get pilots and flight attendants from the two airlines to agree on integrated employment contracts.

After filing for bankruptcy last year, American Airlines parent AMR Corp. threw out its previous labor contracts and jumped into strained contract negotiations with its pilots. AMR contended American Airlines pilots filed an unusually high number of last-minute maintenance work orders in September, delaying hundreds of flights, in a bid to coerce management into reaching a deal. The pilots’ union conceded that the pilots filed the maintenance orders but only because it was required of them. The pilots voted this month to approve a new labor contract.

By cutting competition, a merger between American and US Airways may push up fares but not significantly, said University of California-Irvine professor Jan Brueckner, who coauthored a report on the effects of airline mergers. In the end, he said, cost savings created by the merger would more than make up for the higher fares.

“This impact is likely to be dwarfed by the network benefits enjoyed by passengers and by the cost synergies of the merger, some of which will eventually be passed on to consumers,” Brueckner said.

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service