Study: N.C. too slow to warn about Yadkin fish contamination

Associated PressMay 13, 2013 

  • Charlotte area fish-consumption warnings

    Lake Norman: The state recommends that pregnant and nursing women, women who might become pregnant, and children under 15 not eat striped bass or largemouth bass caught in Lake Norman. Other people should eat no more than two meals a month of largemouth bass and one meal a week of striped bass.

    Mountain Island Lake: The health division recommends that no one eat channel catfish from Mountain Island. Pregnant or nursing women and children should not eat blue catfish or largemouth bass. Others should not eat more than two meals a month of largemouth bass or more than one meal a month of blue catfish.

— Fish in one of North Carolina’s largest watersheds are more polluted by an industrial contaminant than previously reported, and state health officials have failed to expand warnings against eating PCB-contaminated fish, according to a new study.

After more than a year of research and internal discussions, the state Department of Health and Human Services on Monday released its study of PCB contamination along a stretch of the Yadkin River near a shuttered aluminum smelter that Alcoa Inc. operated for nearly a century.

The study’s release came hours before state environmental officials were scheduled to hold a community meeting Monday evening near the closed smelter to discuss the research.

Environmentalists represented by Duke University law professor Ryke Longest collected data from the study under a public records request.

He wrote State Health Director Laura Gerald two weeks ago, saying the agency has known the breadth of PCB pollution for some time and “has not acted to protect the public health” by expanding warnings against eating fish from two reservoirs in addition to the one where the notice has been posted since 2009.

“Every day in which fish consumption advisories are delayed is another day the public stands unprotected,” Longest wrote.

State public health officials have warned since 2009 against eating largemouth bass and catfish caught in Badin Lake, located east of Charlotte, because they had elevated PCB levels. Alcoa contested the 2009 fish warnings in a state administrative court.

There also has been a statewide advisory since 2002 warning pregnant women and children under 15 against eating catfish or other species whose feeding results in mercury collecting in their bodies, state health officials said. Everyone else is encouraged to limit consumption of those fish.

“As the report that will be released Monday will substantiate, the existing fish consumption advisory for mercury is sufficient to protect the public health against the concentration of PCBs found in fish studied in High Rock Lake, Falls Reservoir, and Lake Tillery,” DHHS spokesman Ricky Diaz said.

Polychlorinated biphenyls, or PCBs, are chemicals formerly used as coolants and transformer lubricants that were released into the environment through manufacturing, or improper disposal and storage of electrical equipment.

PCBs have been shown to cause cancer in animals, as well as affect their immune, reproductive, nervous and endocrine systems, the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency says on its website. Human studies provide supportive evidence but are less definitive, the federal agency said.

Alcoa has acknowledged it probably is responsible for the PCB contamination in sediment near the defunct smelter on the southern shore of Badin Lake. But state officials said four years ago that most of the contaminated fish found in the lake came from its northern end. Health officials said the PCBs could have traveled by air, and Alcoa said they might have come from upstream.

The study was intended to better pinpoint the problem.

“This is a watershed issue that is not specific to Alcoa, but associated with industrial and municipal discharges upstream,” Alcoa relicensing manager E. Ray Barham said in a statement.

The study comes as state environmental regulators are considering whether to certify that the company’s operation of four hydroelectric dams built decades ago to power the Alcoa smelter won’t harm water quality in the Yadkin River. That certification is needed for Alcoa to renew its 50-year federal hydroelectric license.

A public hearing on the water quality certification is scheduled for Tuesday in Albemarle.

Electricity generated by the dams no longer is used to power the smelter, which once employed nearly 1,000. The power is now sold on the wholesale market, and Alcoa keeps any profits.

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service