The Wake County Taxpayers Association has fired the first public shot against the $810 million school bond issue that will appear before voters in October. And supporters fired right back, asserting that approval of the bonds is essential to meeting the needs of school-system growth.
The nonprofit taxpayers group, which has aligned itself against tax increases in Wake since forming in 1994, voted recently to oppose the measure, said board Chairman Ed Jones, a Raleigh businessman. The group says the Wake system should make better use of existing space, including portable classrooms. The association further says that growth projections dont take into account the number of students leaving the public system for charter, private and home schooling.
We didnt take an unofficial position until we had all the facts, Jones said Tuesday, citing an analysis by retired consultant Anthony Pecoraro, the groups vice president of external affairs. The analysis that he has come up with is that now, and in the near future, we do not need additional buildings. We have plenty of classroom space if the system uses the classroom space efficiently.
School board Chairman Keith Sutton and Phil Zachary, president of Curtis Media Group and one of three leaders of a group supporting the bond issue, strongly disputed the groups findings.
The need is clear, Sutton said. Were still growing by 3,000 new students in a slow economy. When the economy was robust, we were growing by 5,000 to 7,000 students.
Sutton said that although he hasnt seen the taxpayers associations numbers, school facility staff members have looked at them and reached a different conclusion.
Theyre just dead wrong, Sutton said of the groups numbers.
Pecoraro said his analysis is based in part on the existence of more than 600 portable classrooms, which he said could provide seats for an estimated 15,000 students. The analysis did not examine whether reassignment would be necessary to make best use of seats throughout the system.
Reassignment is something that happens every September, so theres nothing new about that, Pecoraro said.
Zachary said that the bond money requested, with an accompanying tax increase of about $145 on an average home, will pay not only for building schools but also for new equipment needed for schools to keep pace with an evolving society.
We cant teach kids with blackboards when they are sitting there with iPhones in their backpacks, he said. Its incredibly short-sighted to predict what we will need or what we wont need.
The taxpayers association takes the position that Wake County schools should not be increasing the countys overall indebtedness even if the amount proposed wouldnt affect its bond rating.
You dont spend money on things that you dont need, just because it doesnt affect your credit rating, Pecoraro said.
Sutton said passing the bond issue is the responsible thing to do to ensure that Wake doesnt fall behind in capacity, as it did after a school bond issue failed in 1999.
To say that we dont need it is irresponsible, he said.
Staff writer T. Keung Hui contributed to this report.