In My Opinion

Jonathan Stewart’s injury a danger sign for Carolina Panthers

sfowler@charlotteobserver.comAugust 28, 2013 


Carolina Panthers running back Jonathan Stewart (28) will miss the first five games of the season, at least, and others, including Mike Tolbert (35), need to fill the void.


  • Stewart, year-by-year

    Jonathan Stewart’s year-by-year rushing yards since the Panthers drafted him out of Oregon in the first round of the 2008 draft.

    2008 — 836

    2009 — 1,133

    2010 — 770

    2011 — 761

    2012 — 336

    NOTE: Stewart will miss at least the first five games of the 2013 season with an ankle injury.

In what has been a quiet training camp and exhibition season so far, the Panthers have now suffered their first major loss.

Jonathan Stewart can be a beast when he’s healthy – remember that 206-yard game he had against the Giants in 2009? But he hasn’t been healthy for a while now. Stewart was placed on the physically unable to perform list Tuesday, meaning he must miss Thursday’s exhibition against Pittsburgh and at least the first five games of the season.

His absence certainly isn’t unexpected, but it is the most dangerous thing that has happened to the Panthers in the past couple of months. It’s more significant than firing Geoff Hangartner or figuring out that neither Joe Adams nor Edmund Kugbila will play for Carolina in 2013.

Stewart may not play the whole year, either – there’s no certainty that five games (and one bye) worth of missed time will get him healed. If he doesn’t play at all this year – and he won’t be eligible until the Oct. 20 game against St. Louis – then DeAngelo Williams sure better not get hurt.

I’m fine with Mike Tolbert as a change-of-pace back but not the primary one, and right now he’s hurt too with a hamstring problem (although he may be ready by the Seattle game Sept. 8). And Kenjon Barner, Armond Smith or Tauren Poole? I don’t think any of them are ready to play a really significant role, so that would be scary.

So would Cam Newton leading this team in rushing again, like he did last year, because that opens the quarterback up to too many hits.

The bottom line is that Tolbert needs to channel his inner Stewart, which is possible – he also catches the ball and runs well between the tackles.

Those who watch Panthers practice regularly have seen Stewart, the Panthers’ second all-time leading rusher behind Williams in both yards and rush touchdowns, grimacing in pain even after slight exertion. So obviously he’s not right. He had surgery on both ankles in the offseason. He also missed the final seven games of last year with injuries. Like Jon Beason, he signed a huge contract extension not that long ago and has mostly been hurt since.

Running backs, of course, do not last forever. As DeShaun Foster once said when asked why he seemed to be hurt so often during his Panthers career: “I do have 11 people chasing me. They’re all bigger than me.”

Stewart, who is 5 feet, 10-inches tall and 235 pounds is bigger than some pursuers, but the point remains that backs take an incredible pounding.

Stewart can play the piano beautifully by ear, but it’s hard to find a melody in what’s happening to him right now. Double Trouble is in some trouble. It’s now down to Single Trouble — and a lot of hoping.

Fowler:; Twitter: @scott_fowler

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service