Bluegrass vs. old-time music: A primer

dmenconi@newsobserver.comSeptember 23, 2013 

  • Roots and branches

    Within bluegrass there are branches that stretch out – sometimes far out – from the roots. Here are just a few of the main subgenres you might hear during IBMA week and beyond:

    Newgrass: Also called progressive bluegrass, this music has roots in the classic bluegrass sound; but it branches out in new directions, often heavily influenced by rock, pop, jazz or even classical. Sounds like: Punch Brothers, Sam Bush, Alison Krauss, Bela Fleck.

    Jamgrass: The Grateful Dead wasn’t a bluegrass band, but it influenced this subgenre of bluegrass that features the usual instruments (and then some) on songs that start with a groove and journey to … who knows? Sounds like: String Cheese Incident, the Waybacks, Leftover Salmon, Railroad Earth.

    Bluegrass gospel: It’s hard to find a bluegrass band that doesn’t have at least a song or two about faith in its repertoire, but some bands focus almost exclusively on songs of praise. Vocals and multi-part harmonies are front and center in this category. Sounds like: The Lewis Family, The Isaacs, Canaan’s Crossing, Blue Highway.

    Staff writer Stacy Chandler

  • A note about banjos

    A banjo does not a bluegrass band make. Despite having long been the butt of countless jokes in the music world, the banjo is suddenly having a moment in the sun. Mumford & Sons, Modest Mouse and North Carolina’s own The Avett Brothers have scored hits with a banjo in the band, and many of those acts have headlined bluegrass festivals. But those bands don’t claim to be bluegrass bands. Bluegrass – and banjos – are just some ingredients in the alchemy that goes into the sound with which these bands have found success.

    Staff writer Stacy Chandler

— It’s common to see “bluegrass” and “old-time” used as almost interchangeable labels, especially in the years since roots music went mainstream with the chart-topping soundtrack to 2000’s “O Brother, Where Art Thou?” But while the styles are closely related and have similar instrumentation, bluegrass and old-time are not the same.

While this is a gross over-simplification, here are the two quickest ways to tell whether a band is bluegrass or old-time:

• Type of banjo – In old-time, it’s typically an open-back model. Bluegrass banjo has a resonator and is louder.

• Solos – Everyone just plays the song straight on through in old-time, which rarely has individual solos. In bluegrass, there are “breaks,” interludes in which each instrumentalist takes a lead solo while the rest of the players stick to the main melody.

Beyond those generalizations, you could do a lot worse than to ask local musician Joe Newberry (who has been known to play both bluegrass and old-time) to break it down.

“Bluegrass and old-time are vines from the same root,” says Newberry, who won an International Bluegrass Music Association award in 2012 and is nominated again this year. “Old-time is one of many roots of bluegrass, and it has many mothers and fathers as well – African influences with banjo, Scots-Irish fiddle, church and dance traditions. All of these were things folks used to relax at the end of the day and sometimes made hard lives easier to bear.”

Poole’s influence

Early on, old-time was mostly instrumental string-band music suitable for square-dancing, with fiddle as primary lead instrument. Banjo was also prominent, played in a “clawhammer” style with the right hand stroking down on the strings.

Spray native Charlie Poole came along during the roaring ’20s and moved old-time closer to what eventually became both bluegrass and country music. But it took Bill Monroe, the “father of bluegrass,” to create bluegrass by adding his own special blue-note flourishes. When Shelby native Earl Scruggs joined Monroe’s Blue Grass Boys in the mid-1940s and added his “Scruggs-style” three-finger banjo rolls, it caused a sensation.

“It was astounding to people,” Newberry says. “When you listen to their early recordings, it almost sounds like the Beatles from everybody yelling and screaming and carrying on.”

There are, of courses, purists in both bluegrass and old-time camps, which creates fertile ground for parody. Earlier this year, the website Bluegrass Nation ( bluegrassnation.org) hilariously delineated the differences between bluegrass, old-time and Celtic music:

Old Time and Celtic songs are about whiskey, food and struggle. Bluegrass songs are about God, mother and the girl who did me wrong. If the girl isn’t dead by the third verse, it ain’t Bluegrass. If everyone dies, it’s Celtic.

“Things like that are funny, and they always have grains of truth,” Newberry says. “The problem with stereotypes is a lot of people don’t look past them. But old-time is like anything else – some people just play at it while others play it. Bluegrass is the same way. High-level players will make high-level music no matter the style.”

Menconi: 919-829-4759 or blogs.newsobserver.com/beat

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service