Road Worrier

Road Worrier: Drivers hope new NC licenses won't crack, fade, break

bsiceloff@newsobserver.comJanuary 20, 2014 

Stephen Gheen of Durham used tape to mend his cracked and faded North Carolina driver’s license.

COURTESY OF STEPHEN GHEEN

  • Drivers talk about what’s in their wallets

    “A corner has broken off. The picture faded as well. On a good note, I have lost 70 pounds, so it is time to get a new picture.”

    James Kantor, Raleigh


    “I realize I’m not Rock Hudson, but I would like to be able to show the picture on my license when needed, without looking like I lost my nose, one eye and my left cheek.”

    Ray Eason, Durham


    “I have never, never liked pictures of myself – the reason being they always look like me. My present N.C. license photo is the worst ever.”

    Patrica Parker, Raleigh


    “My license was issued in March of 2011, and it split and I taped it, and that split. I went to a license office, and they issued a new one, and now it has split. I guess the plastic doesn’t like the curvature of my butt.”

    Clarence Siler, Raleigh


    “Right about the time it really needed to be renewed, that thin plastic was starting to come off. It was driving me crazy. I wanted to peel it off.”

    Reggie Revis, Fuquay-Varina


    “You look at what an awful picture it is, but it’s really me. I love my license. It was the inspiration to change my life. My license inspired me to go to the gym almost every day for about five years now, and drop about 25 pounds.”

    Joseph Herrin, Chapel Hill


    “I got one of the driver’s licenses where the photo faded out almost entirely. DMV issued a replacement for free (after two hours waiting in line for it). The replacement cracked down the length of the card.”

    Stephen Gheen, Durham

— North Carolina’s “next generation” of driver’s licenses will feature the latest facial-recognition technology. That’s nice if it means you’ll be able to recognize the face in your license photo.

The state Division of Motor Vehicles says the new licenses will be strengthened to resist counterfeiters and thwart identity thieves. But will they crack under pressure in your hip pocket?

Triangle drivers tell the Road Worrier that their North Carolina driver’s licenses are fading, splitting, peeling and breaking. They repair them with tape. They get replacements from DMV. The replacements go bad, too.

“Mine is faded and scratched for sure,” Bob Davis, 55, of Raleigh said by email. “The line which once read ROBERT HENRY DAVIS now reads RO ERT IEI DAVI. The photo now looks like someone, but that someone is not me.”

Charlie Stephenson of Raleigh ran into trouble at the airport when a TSA officer asked to see his photo ID. He pulled out one piece of his license, but the other piece was stuck in his wallet.

“I was questioned about how the ID got broken and why it had not been replaced,” said Stephenson, 50, a high school physics teacher. “I explained that the edge had recently broken off.”

On the return trip, TSA officers in Tampa, Fla., had Stephenson dig out his schoolteacher ID, Social Security card and a few credit cards to confirm his identity. He ordered a new license from DMV after he made it home.

“In less than one year, the corner of the replacement (license) has broken off,” Stephenson said. “I will need to pay to have it replaced if I plan to fly again.”

Dave Davenport’s license “always cracks after a few years,” and he thinks he knows why.

“The way it sits in my wallet, it has a lot of pressure from me sitting on it. That would be my guess,” said Davenport, 54, of Holly Springs. “It’s very brittle plastic. More brittle than a credit card, and I’ve never had any credit card do that.”

Long line of upgrades

DMV launches a license upgrade every seven to 10 years – frequently with the stated purpose of making life harder for underage drinkers, identity thieves, criminals and immigrants in the country illegally. Somehow the priorities never seem to include better durability.

The modern credit card-style was introduced in 1996 to replace Polaroid laminated licenses dating to the 1960s. The new cards included barcodes to give police officers quicker roadside access to drivers’ records. Soon there were holograms and other security measures aimed at discouraging counterfeiters.

Some of the most important security upgrades don’t show up in the individual licenses themselves. Since 2004, DMV has incorporated facial-recognition technology into the process of producing licenses. Each of the 8,000 to 9,000 license and ID photos taken across the state every day is digitally scanned to measure distance between the eyes and other facial geometry – so it can be compared with all photos in the license database.

That’s how DMV caught up with an enterprising individual in Edgecombe County who had obtained licenses using 23 different names, but each time using the same telltale face. Gov. Mike Easley declared in 2004 that the state would begin checking drivers’ photos against a federal government terrorist watch list, but DMV officials say that never happened.

A silver-foil hologram was added in 2006, criticized in 2007 by conspiracy theorists who saw dark meaning in its ambiguous imagery, and eliminated in 2008.

In 2010, DMV announced a big leap forward with new licenses that would feature vivid, 3-D mugshots laser-etched in black-and-white. But work stalled on the state’s seven-year, $47.5 million contract with MorphoTrak-Safran Group. DMV had spent $5 million by the time the contract was canceled in December.

Now there’s a $73.5 million contract with a different company that has a deceptively similar name. DMV had worked since 1999 with the vendor previously known as L-1 Identity Solutions. The French firm Safran bought L-1 in 2011 and renamed it MorphoTrust of USA. The new licenses will go into production in 2015.

The MorphoTrust contract costs more, DMV says, partly because it covers more than just the yearly production of 2 million licenses and ID cards themselves. There are plans to add more photo stations at DMV offices to reduce waiting times. DMV also says local license examiners now will have “real-time facial recognition capability.” That means they should be able to evaluate your image immediately, to figure out whether you’re that sneaky guy from Edgecombe County.

The MorphoTrust contract announcement said almost nothing about the new license itself. In response to questions from the Road Worrier, DMV spokeswoman Marge Howell said the new license will have color mugshots, not 3-D laser engravings. While the current licenses are made of PVC, she said, the new ones will use a material “with longer durability” called Exian Evident.

Replacing defective cards

But will the new cards crack? Fade? Peel? Will they last as long as the other cards we carry in our wallets?

“DMV has full confidence that the chosen material will hold up during the issuance period,” Howell said by email. “It is a distinguishing feature of the card that the vendor guarantees a 10-year life expectancy of the card. DMV issues licenses and cards for periods of five and eight years.”

Meanwhile, Howell says, there are two ways to get a replacement for your old, defective driver’s license. You can request a duplicate license online for a $10 fee. Or take the bad one to a DMV driver’s license office for a new one, free of charge.

Siceloff: 919-829-4527 or newsobserver.com/roadworrierblog Twitter: @Road_Worrier

News & Observer is pleased to provide this opportunity to share information, experiences and observations about what's in the news. Some of the comments may be reprinted elsewhere in the site or in the newspaper. We encourage lively, open debate on the issues of the day, and ask that you refrain from profanity, hate speech, personal comments and remarks that are off point. Thank you for taking the time to offer your thoughts.

Commenting FAQs | Terms of Service