In the Tar Heel State, the most contentious law is what the seven justices of the N.C. Supreme Court say it is. Who the justices are, though, is up to the voters and, on Nov. 7, a majority of justices will be selected for eight-year terms.

Chief Justice Sarah Parker is running to keep the job that Governor Easley appointed her to earlier this year. So is Associate Justice Patricia Timmons-Goodson, who was named to Parker's prior seat. Two judges presently on the state Court of Appeals are vying for the seat that will come open with the retirement of Associate Justice George L. Wainwright Jr., and Associate Justice Mark Martin is running for a second term on the court. All four races are contested but nonpartisan.

Daily, the high court reviews the work of other judges, and, for all who sit on death row, its decisions are a life-and-death matter. Beyond a deep knowledge of the law and sharp analytical skills, the justices must apply the wisdom that comes from experience. As a group, it's important for the justices to identify with people of many backgrounds.

After interviewing many of the candidates and reviewing their records, The News & Observer offers its editorial endorsements, on Sunday in the chief justice race, and today in the associate justice races:

* Robin Hudson, 54, of Raleigh was the first woman elected to the state Court of Appeals without first having been appointed to a seat. During her seven years on the court, Hudson has built a reputation for thorough preparation and articulate, forthright discussion of legal issues. Her talents are well-suited to the demands of the appellate bench, with its heavy emphasis on research and writing. Broad appellate experience in private practice adds to her credentials. She has degrees from Yale University and the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill School of Law.

Her opponent, Ann Marie Calabria, 59, of Morrisville also is a Court of Appeals judge. She was elected four years ago after serving on the Wake County District Court bench. Calabria's six years on the lower-level trial court provided her with insight into the operations of another important branch of the justice system. She was educated at Fairleigh Dickinson University in Teaneck, N.J., and Campbell University School of Law in Buies Creek.

Calabria is running for the Supreme Court out of a desire to see cases expedited. She's concerned that children are staying in foster care too long while legal issues in abuse, neglect and dependency cases are sorted out in the courts. She describes herself as a judicial conservative, although she properly emphasizes that she is bound to follow the law in all cases, personal views notwithstanding. If Calabria is defeated in this race, she will remain on the Court of Appeals.

Hudson says that she would bring no agenda to the high court, striving to be impartial as well as reasoned and clear in the opinions she writes. Her record during eight years on the appeals court bears out her ability to meet those standards. Considering both her experience and performance, she shapes up as the better choice.

* Patricia Timmons-Goodson, 52, of Fayetteville was a Cumberland County District Court judge for 12 1/2 years before former Gov. Jim Hunt appointed her to the appeals court in 1997. She won election to a full term the following year. In 2002, Timmons-Goodson served on the first appellate court panel of three black female judges in the state's history, but she has a reputation for being colorblind in her decisions. She graduated from UNC-Chapel Hill and UNC's law school.

Next page >