Agents' Secrets

Duane Deaver's work paved the path for Michael Peterson's new trial. His testimony also could force another look at the sentences of several other convicted murderers.

Modified: 01/22/12 10:06:17 PM
PDF
Supportive and dismissive letters about Duane Deaver
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series
Link
See the cases flagged as troubling by an audit of the SBI

When Superior Court Judge Orlando Hudson ordered a new trial for Durham author Michael Peterson, he uttered a phrase seldom used by a judge describing the conduct of an SBI agent on the witness stand: "perjured testimony."

Modified: 12/18/11 05:53:25 AM
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series
gallery
Michael Peterson leaves jail | 12.15.11
gallery
Peterson gets new trial | 12.14.11

Modified: 12/14/11 11:35:48 PM

Durham novelist Michael Peterson walked out of the Durham County Jail shortly after 6 p.m. today, joining his family for the first time after eight years in prison. Peterson spoke briefly after leaving the jail, saying he looks forward to proving his innocence in a "fair trial."

Modified: 01/19/12 12:47:29 PM
gallery
Michael Peterson leaves jail | 12.15.11
gallery
Peterson gets new trial | 12.14.11
Story
Defense challenged Deaver at trial in 2003
Story
Time line: The Michael Peterson case
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series

Michael Peterson's hearing for a new trial this month was not the first time his defense team had challenged the credentials of former State Bureau of Investigation agent Duane Deaver.

Modified: 12/14/11 11:30:50 PM

State Bureau of Investigation records of former agent Duane Deaver's cases show that Deaver had not done any work involving people hurt or killed in falls when he testified at the murder trial of Durham novelist Michael Peterson, according to testimony Tuesday.

Modified: 12/14/11 09:20:03 AM
gallery
Michael Peterson's new trial hearing | 12.13.11
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series
Link
See the cases flagged as troubling by an audit of the SBI

The Michael Peterson hearing took on some trappings of a film festival Thursday, somehow appropriate for a criminal case that has spawned documentaries and a feature film.

Modified: 12/09/11 06:56:24 AM
gallery
Peterson hearing | 12.08.11
gallery
Peterson fights for new trial | 12.06.11
gallery
Michael Peterson hearing continues | 12.07.11
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series

To win a new trial, Durham novelist Michael Peterson and his lawyers are arguing that former SBI agent Duane Deaver tailored his expert witness testimony not to the facts or science of a case, but to what prosecutors wanted him to say.

Modified: 12/08/11 08:10:16 AM
gallery
Michael Peterson hearing continues | 12.07.11
gallery
Peterson fights for new trial | 12.06.11
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series
Link
See the cases flagged as troubling by an audit of the SBI

A story and a photo caption on Wednesday about the Michael Peterson court hearing incorrectly spelled the name of SBI Assistant Director Erik Hooks.

Modified: 12/08/11 06:18:29 AM

Former SBI agent Duane Deaver showed a strong bias for the prosecution early in his career, according to SBI documents introduced in the Michael Peterson hearing today. Peterson, a Durham novelist convicted of the 2001 murder of his wife, has said he deserves a new trial because of Deaver's testimony.

Modified: 01/27/12 03:26:52 PM
gallery
Michael Peterson hearing continues | 12.07.11
Story
SBI says Deaver exaggerated expertise
Story
Judge asked to rescind order on prison records
gallery
Peterson fights for new trial | 12.06.11
Link
See the cases flagged as troubling by an audit of the SBI

Former SBI agent Duane Deaver misrepresented agency policy and exaggerated his training and experience under oath when he was certified as an expert witness in the Michael Peterson trial, according to SBI records and the SBI internal affairs director.

Modified: 01/27/12 03:26:52 PM
gallery
Peterson fights for new trial | 12.06.11
Story
Judge asked to rescind order on prison records
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series
Link
See the cases flagged as troubling by an audit of the SBI
Link
Read more on Tracey Cline in the Twisted Truth series

A story on Tuesday about Michael Peterson's return to Durham to seek a re-trial on his murder conviction inaccurately described two family members who were in the courtroom supporting him. Peterson raised Margaret and Martha Ratliff after their parents died. The story also should have said that Peterson had claimed two Purple Hearts from his military service in Vietnam, not three.

Modified: 12/07/11 07:35:22 AM

While Attorney General Roy Cooper's office defends the state's decision to fire former SBI agent Duane Deaver, lawyers from Cooper's staff are willing to defend Deaver's work in winning the 2003 murder conviction of Durham novelist Michael Peterson.

Modified: 01/27/12 03:26:52 PM
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series
Story
Judge dismisses all three of Cline's courtroom claims
PDF
Email regarding Cline's conflict-of-interest motion

When Michael Peterson returns to the Durham courthouse this week seeking a new trial, the author and convicted murderer will be sitting in the defendant's seat. But former State Bureau of Investigation agent Duane Deaver will be the person under the most duress.

Modified: 01/27/12 03:26:52 PM
Story
Cline's motions could stall trial
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series
Link
Read more on Tracey Cline in the Twisted Truth series

When court convenes in Durham on Monday, it's anybody's guess what will happen.

Modified: 12/03/11 07:42:54 PM
Agents' Secrets: The Fallout More

Duane Deaver's work paved the path for Michael Peterson's new trial. His testimony also could force another look at the sentences of several other convicted murderers.

Modified: 01/22/12 10:06:17 PM

When court convenes in Durham on Monday, it's anybody's guess what will happen.

Modified: 12/03/11 07:42:54 PM

A State Bureau of Investigation agent dropped her lawsuit against The News & Observer, almost three months after accusing the publishing company of making "false, despicable and defamatory statements" about her in its award-winning investigative series, "Agents' Secrets."

Modified: 12/03/11 06:51:27 AM
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series

Agents' Secrets: Day One:  SBI agents have cut corners, bullied the vulnerable and twisted reports and court testimony when the truth threatened to undermine their cases, our investigation of the SBI's work, policies and practices reveals.

Modified: 08/02/11 12:29:11 PM
gallery
Inside the SBI lab
gallery
Floyd Brown: Held 17 years for a murder he didn't commit
video
Agents' Secrets: A confession doesn't add up
PDF
Judge releases Floyd Brown
PDF
Full text of Floyd Brown's confession

Agents' Secrets: Day Two:  Attorney General Roy Cooper suspended the unit that handles bloodstain pattern analysis, which hid results and ran bizarre experiments.

Modified: 08/02/11 12:29:11 PM
gallery
Inside the SBI lab
gallery
Floyd Brown: Held 17 years for a murder he didn't commit
video
Agents' Secrets-Junk Science
PDF
Original t-shirt description (page 2)
PDF
Modified t-shirt description (page 2)

Agents' Secrets: Day Three:  The work of the SBI crime lab has been under fire since February, when Greg Taylor, an innocent man, was freed after judges learned an SBI serologist withheld crucial evidence that proved a stain on Taylor's SUV wasn't blood.

Modified: 08/02/11 12:29:11 PM
PDF
Stanly County DA's memo on how to train analysts
gallery
Inside the SBI lab
gallery
Floyd Brown: Held 17 years for a murder he didn't commit
video
Agent's Secrets: A truth seeps out at last
PDF
Former guidelines for SBI analysts in court (until Aug. 11, 2010)

Agents' Secrets: Day Four:  Attorney General Roy Cooper has asked his new director, Greg McLeod, to review the work of the firearms identification unit, citing concerns raised by The N&O this summer.

Modified: 08/24/11 09:47:55 AM
gallery
Inside the SBI lab
gallery
Floyd Brown: Held 17 years for a murder he didn't commit
PDF
Beth Desmond's report on two bullet fragments
Story
Sitting on death row 14 years, judged on three sets of bullets
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series

A story Saturday about the firearms unit of the SBI lab incorrectly reported the adjudication of a Wilson County murder case in which a lab analyst was forbidden from testifying. That trial ended in a hung jury.

Modified: 08/20/10 04:50:40 AM

Saunders:  OK, it's easy to understand why Attorney General Roy Cooper hasn't fired that Isley brother, but it's harder to figure out how Duane Deaver still has a job with the state.

Modified: 10/13/10 07:18:35 PM

Saunders:  Hey, wait a minute. You don't reckon all of those dudes were telling the truth, do you?

Modified: 08/09/10 11:19:35 PM

Union County District Attorney John Snyder said Tuesday that he will review all past homicide cases in his district to ensure that none have been tainted by mistakes from the crime lab at the State Bureau of Investigation.

Modified: 03/27/11 04:44:19 AM
Link
Read more in the Agents' Secrets series

Contact the N&O newsroom

Thad Ogburn, metro editor
(919) 829-8987

Richard Stradling, deputy metro editor
(919) 829-4739

Deborah Jackson, night metro editor
(919) 829-8920

Newsroom main number: (919) 829-4520

All newsroom contacts

Get local news updates

Keep up with the latest stories with our free local news e-mail newsletters, delivered straight to your inbox!

- it's free!

- it's free!

- it's free!

- it's free!

- it's free!

- it's free!

- it's free!

Hot Deals View All
Find a Car
Go
Top Jobs View All

Find a Job
Go
Featured Homes View All
Find a Home
Go

News Blogs & Columnists

Print Ads