From Staff Reports
CHAPEL HILL - It's not just sugary sodas that are adding to the obesity
crisis - it's fruit drinks, alcohol and a combination of other
high-calorie beverages, say UNC-Chapel Hill
School of Public Health researchers. And during the holidays, when
eggnog, cocktails and spiced cider are abundant, the problem can be even
more apparent.
Over the past 37 years, the number of calories adults get through
beverages has nearly doubled, according to a UNC study published in the
November issue of Obesity Research by Kiyah J. Duffey, a doctoral
candidate in the department of nutrition, and Barry M. Popkin, Ph.D.,
professor of nutrition and a fellow at the Carolina Population Center.
The study used nationally representative data to quantify both trends
and patterns in beverage consumption among 46,576 American adults age
19 and older. Patterns and trends of all beverages adults consumed were
examined between 1965 and 2002. Researchers found that, over these 37
years, total daily intake of calories from beverages increased by 94
percent, providing an average 21 percent of daily energy intake among
U.S. adults. That amounts to an additional 222 calories from all
beverages daily.
Water intake was measured from 1989 to 2002, and during that time, the
amount of water consumed stayed roughly the same, but the average adult
consumed an additional 21 ounces per day of other beverages, Popkin
said.
"This has considerable implications for numerous health outcomes,
including obesity and diabetes as this is just adding several hundred
calories daily to our overall caloric intake," Popkin said.
Most researchers agree that beverages do not fill you up, Popkin said.
"Regardless of beverage type - water, sodas, milk, orange juice or beer
- those extra calories are not compensated for by a reduction in food
intake."
Data analyzed for this study came from the federally funded Nationwide
Food Consumption Surveys of 1965 and 1977-1978 and the National Health
and Nutrition Examination Surveys of 1989-1994 and 1999-2002.
"For each exam year, we calculated total energy intake, percent
consuming and calories per consumer for 16 different beverages, and
determined total beverage intake (fluid ounces) for each beverage,"
Duffey said. "Then, using a method that finds patterns within data, we
generated 5 different groups of individuals who had similar patterns of
beverage consumption and compared the beverages that comprised these
groups in 1977 and 2002 to determine if the combinations of beverages
were different."
As it turns out, they were different.
"The biggest difference we observed was that the 2002 beverage patterns
were more complex than they were in 1977," she said. "For example, just
five beverages dominated the patterns in 1977, but in 2002 there were
eight beverages consumed in significant quantities - and new beverages
appeared in these 2002 patterns. Fruit and vegetable juices and diet
beverages were not important in 1977 patterns, but were in 2002."
Equally important, Popkin noted, are the overall trends in total
calories from beverages. In 1965, beverages accounted for just 12
percent of daily energy intake. That number jumped to 21 percent by
2002.
As noted in previous studies, 23 percent more adults reported drinking
soda between 1965 and 2002 (accounting for an additional 108 calories
per day) while calories from whole-fat milk declined nearly 45 percent
(from 119 calories per day in 1965 to 69 calories per day in 2002).
Alcohol (up 73 calories per day) and fruit juice (up 20 calories per
day) had considerable increases in their contribution to daily energy
intake as well.
"One of the strengths of this study," Popkin said, "is that we examined
the full range of beverages consumed, providing a broad understanding of
the role of beverages, and patterns of beverages, to overall dietary
intake."
Because data are not collected on the same individuals over time,
conclusions cannot be made about the influence of the observed trends or
patterns on changes in individual health outcomes over time, but they
can provide a starting point for future analyses to examine this issue.
All rights reserved. This copyrighted material may not be published, broadcast or redistributed in any manner.