The Opinion Shop

January 21, 2014

NYT blog post explores what happens when poor among Cherokee in NC receive a stipend

NYT blog post by Moises Velasquez-Manoff explores what happens when the poor among Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians in NC receive stipends from casino profits.

Here’s a fascinating piece by Moises Velasquez-Manoff on the NYT Opinionator blog site detailing how the lives of poor children among the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians in NC vastly improved when their families started receiving stipends from casino profits. Why? The short answer is that being freed from constant worry over finances, parents were able to spend more energy being better parents.

Here’s a look:

Growing up poor has long been associated with reduced educational attainment and lower lifetime earnings. Some evidence also suggests a higher risk of depression, substance abuse and other diseases in adulthood. Even for those who manage to overcome humble beginnings, early-life poverty may leave a lasting mark, accelerating aging and increasing the risk of degenerative disease in adulthood.

Today more than one in five American children live in poverty. How, if at all, to intervene is almost invariably a politically fraught question. Scientists interested in the link between poverty and mental health, however, often face a more fundamental problem: a relative dearth of experiments that test and compare potential interventions.

So when, in 1996, the Eastern Band of Cherokee Indians in North Carolina’s Great Smoky Mountains opened a casino, Jane Costello, an epidemiologist at Duke University Medical School, saw an opportunity. The tribe elected to distribute a proportion of the profits equally among its 8,000 members. Professor Costello wondered whether the extra money would change psychiatric outcomes among poor Cherokee families.

Read the rest here.

Related content



About Greg Cote

The Opinion Shop logo

The Opinion Shop

Welcome to The Opinion Shop, where members of The N&O’s editorial board offer an eclectic array of their individual opinion products and give you an opportunity to offer your own.

Editor's Choice Videos