News & Observer | newsobserver.com | Packer boxes out the haters

Published: Mar 23, 2008 12:30 AM
Modified: Mar 23, 2008 06:49 AM

Packer boxes out the haters

Billy Packer, left, has his say while preparing for a telecast during the ACC Tournament in Charlotte.

Story Tools


Packer on the segments of his life.


Packer on his approach to ACC games and why fans don't like it.


Packer on broadcasting regrets and his view of Gerald Henderson and Tyler Hansbrough.

HIS Q SCORE

Each year, Marketing Evaluations Inc., based in Manhasset, N.Y., surveys sports fans -- defined as people ages 12 to 64 who are fans of at least one major sport -- to determine their familiarity with and fondness for certain sports figures.

The firm, which counts TV networks and advertisers among its clients, found that in 2007 a below-average 45 percent of sports fans recognized CBS analyst Billy Packer, and he earned a below-average Q Score -- or "likeability" rating -- of 13. In the latter category, he ranked 33rd among 37 sports announcers, in the same range as NFL sideline reporters Michele Tafoya and Tony Siragusa.

Packer's counterpart in NFL longevity, NBC analyst John Madden, ranked No. 1. Familiar to 78 percent of fans, he was given a Q Score of 47.

Demographically, Packer does best among men 50 and older, says Henry Schafer, executive vice president of Marketing Evaluations, who wouldn't say whether CBS is a client or why Packer's Q Score was so low. That analysis is proprietary.

ROGER VAN DER HORST

Advertisements
He's never been a sports fan.

He forgets players' numbers.

He'd rather not rely heavily on instant replay.

He's a walking conflict of interest.

And that's only what Billy Packer says about himself.

As he prepares to work his 34th consecutive NCAA Final Four in college basketball -- a championship record in any sport that CBS partner Jim Nantz predicts will last forever -- Packer doesn't even consider himself a professional broadcaster. His role as the college game's senior spokesman qualifies as merely a "neat segment" in a richly compartmentalized life.

His television career "is not what he does," says his younger brother, Dick.

At 68, Billy Packer is still looking for the next good deal. He's made millions of dollars outside television, much of it in real estate, more than enough to walk away from the microphone whenever he chooses. He's a political junkie who'd just as soon talk about a campaign as he would a season. He collects art, with a particular fondness for Picasso ceramic plates.

Still, he loves to prepare for a game, the studying it takes, as if again measuring himself against other players and coaches, against the game itself. In pregame mode, he shuts out all else. He compartmentalizes.

"Like, if you like a subject in school, to prepare for the test is not a job, it's fun to learn and understand it," Packer says in an interview at his home in Charlotte. "And then when the test comes, it's fun to compete with the other kids in the class, and then when the test comes back, it's fun to get an A.

"To me, that's what broadcasting is."

As soon as the game ends, it's gone, out of his head. He couldn't tell you the starting lineups in a game he worked three days ago.

"I tune that out and don't tune it back in until I'm ready to be in that part of my life again," he says. "I don't sit around daydreaming about basketball all day long."

That helps explain why, after so many years, he hasn't lost his passion for the sport. In whatever daydreams he does allow himself, he hasn't heard a final buzzer yet.

"I know I would definitely not do another game if ... two things were involved," Packer says. " No. 1, I wasn't properly prepared, or at least somebody could prepare better, and No. 2, when I got there I didn't want to be there.

"I don't know how you could fake that. And I'm not talking about the fans. It'd be easy to fake it to the fans and to the listeners. But to yourself ..."

After all, Billy Packer really answers to himself.

The Packer haters

At a point when other broadcasting icons could expect to soak up the adulation of lifelong listeners, Packer takes more hits than a dartboard in a crowded bar. He is described variously as a cranky, inflexible, arrogant old man who's out of touch with the modern game, humorless and unwilling to admit he's wrong.

Google Packer's name, and the Internet search engine spits back a stream of venom.

"CBS -- Please remove Billy Packer from the airwaves," a petition posted by a fellow Wake Forest alumnus, pops up just above CBS' official bio.

Scroll down a couple of spots, and you get to the Awful Announcing Web site's article, "Billy Packer Could Take The Joy Out of Sex," from where it's easy to spot ACC BasketBlog's "Billy Packer Hatred" page.

Packer's Q Score of 13 -- his "likeability" rating -- put him 33rd of 37 sports announcers last year, according to Marketing Evaluations Inc., which annually surveys fans to measure sports figures' familiarity and appeal.

Forrest Maready, the Wake Forest graduate who posted the Packer petition about four years ago, says about 5,300 Web users have "signed" it. A 36-year-old advertising designer in Durham, Maready gives the impression that he's a thoughtful college basketball fan, not prone to obscenity-laced rants, more frustrated than angry.


Next page >

Hosting Partners of
newsobserver.com

Member of the
Real Cities Network

A subsidiary of The McClatchy Company