Just going by surface statistics, NBC appears to be sitting pretty. The network won the 2014-15 TV season in the important age 18-49 demo for the second year in a row, but it achieved that win by the skin of its teeth. CBS was behind by one-tenth of a ratings point – in a year NBC had the Super Bowl.
Furthermore, CBS won the ratings race among total viewers, and even NBC’s biggest hits suffered big ratings declines, including “The Blacklist” (down more than 18 percent in the demo; down almost 12 percent in viewers), “The Voice” (down about 20 percent in the demo on Mondays) and “The Biggest Loser” (down almost 38 percent in the demo; down 30 percent in total viewers).
Add to that the NBC News scandal surrounding fabulist now-deposed “NBC Nightly News” anchor Brian Williams and the virtual abdication of its place as the one-time home for must-see TV comedies – come fall NBC will air just one hour of sitcoms on the lowest-rated night of the week, Friday – and it’s clear NBC has a lot of work to do.
What’s on tap for fall? One big swing (an attempt to resurrect the variety show in “Best Time Ever With Neil Patrick Harris”), one critically panned sitcom (“Truth Be Told”), a reboot (“Heroes Reborn”) and two action shows, each one starring a former cast member from Cinemax’s “Strike Back,” and at least one brings to mind “The Blacklist” (“Blindspot,” “The Player”).
NBC Entertainment chairman Robert Greenblatt acknowledged NBC’s struggle to find comedies that are “classy new anchor shows” for Thursday night and then announced a raft of potential new comedy series that are in the works.
Last year NBC ordered and then later sold the critically acclaimed Emmy-nominated “Unbreakable Kimmy Schmidt” to Netflix. Greenblatt has no regrets.
“We’re whores for Emmy nominations just like everybody else,” he said. “We thought long and hard about the best way to launch this show we also own. … We wanted to put that show in a situation where it had the best chance for success, and we thought the Netflix move was going to be that.”
NBC has moved to trying out comedies in the summer, including the terrible “Mr. Robinson,” which has generated surprisingly respectable ratings. Another sitcom, “The Carmichael Show,” debuts later this month.
NBC is developing a new comedy with “30 Rock” writers Tina Fey, Robert Carlock and Tracey Wigfield about a young woman working at a cable news network whose over-involved mother gets an internship there.
NBC gave a straight-to-series order to “A Good Place” from writer-showrunner Michael Schur, best known for writing/producing “Parks and Recreation” and “Brooklyn Nine-Nine.” Greenblatt said the show will be about a “strong and complicated woman … wrestling with what it means to be good.”
NBC shored up its late-night strategy by renewing Jimmy Fallon’s contract as host of “The Tonight Show” for six more years through 2021.
Holiday classic “How the Grinch Stole Christmas” moves from ABC to NBC for at least the next two years. NBC renewed “American Ninja Warrior” for a fifth season.
There won’t be a “Celebrity Apprentice” in 2015-16, but it will return in the 2016-17 TV season with a new host now that Donald Trump is busy running for president.
Any chance Trump could return if he ends his campaign?
“Absolutely not,” Greenblatt said.