Raleigh News & Observer Logo

Firing of Charlotte investigator over Facebook post fuels free speech debate | Raleigh News & Observer

×
  • E-edition
    • Customer Service
    • Support
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • FAQ
    • Sponsorships
    • Stay connected
    • Mobile & Apps
    • Facebook
    • Google+
    • Instagram
    • Twitter
    • Social Media Directory
    • N&O Store
    • Buy Photos
    • Databases
    • Archives
    • Newsletters

    • Blogs
    • Columnists
    • Crime
    • Education
    • Health
    • Local
    • North Carolina
    • Nation/World
    • Science
    • Thumbs Up
    • Traffic
    • Weather
    • Weird News
    • All News
    • Counties
    • Durham County
    • Johnston County
    • Orange County
    • Wake County
    • All Sports
    • Baseball
    • Canes
    • College
    • Columns & Blogs
    • High Schools
    • NASCAR & Auto Racing
    • NBA
    • NFL
    • NHL
    • Olympics
    • Outdoors
    • Panthers
    • Soccer
    • Schools
    • Duke
    • East Carolina
    • NC State
    • North Carolina
    • All Politics
    • The North Carolina Influencer Series
    • State Politics
    • Blogs
    • Columnists
    • PolitiFact
    • PolitiFact NC
    • Rob Christensen
    • Under the Dome
    • All Business
    • Blogs
    • Columnists
    • Health Care
    • Personal Finance
    • Real Estate
    • Shop Talk
    • Stocks Center
    • Technology
    • All Living
    • Video Now
    • Best-Kept Secrets
    • Blogs
    • Celebrations
    • Comics
    • Family
    • Fashion
    • Fitness
    • Food
    • Games and Puzzles
    • Home and Garden
    • Horoscopes
    • Mouthful
    • Past Times
    • Pets
    • Religion
    • Travel
    • Video Now
    • Arts News
    • ArtsNow
    • Books
    • Contests
    • Dining
    • Entertainment
    • Games
    • Movies
    • Music
    • Nightlife
    • Television
    • On the Beat
    • Happiness is a Warm TV
    • All Opinion
    • Columnists
    • Dwane Powell
    • Editorials
    • Influencers Opinion
    • Letters
    • Opinion Shop Blog
    • Other Views
    • Submit a Letter
  • Obituaries

    • Advertise with us
    • Place Ad
    • Apartments
    • Cars
    • Homes
    • Jobs
    • Legals
    • Obits/In Memoriams
    • Weddings
    • Today's Daily Deal
    • Special Sections
    • Today's Circulars
    • Rewards
    • Photo Store
  • Classifieds
  • Jobs
  • Moonlighting
  • Cars
  • Homes
  • Legals

Latest News

Firing of Charlotte investigator over Facebook post fuels free speech debate

By Lisa Worf - WFAE

    ORDER REPRINT →

December 18, 2014 02:22 PM

A city of Charlotte fire investigator is out of a job because of a Facebook post in the aftermath of the Ferguson, Mo., riots.

It’s the first time a Charlotte city employee has been fired over a posting on social media. An attorney for the investigator said the city overreached.

So what are the First Amendment rights of public employees?

City Manager Ron Carlee said it’s essential the public is confident that city employees will treat all people with dignity and respect.

Sign Up and Save

Get six months of free digital access to The News & Observer

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

#ReadLocal

He believes Crystal Eschert violated that confidence shortly after police officer Darren Wilson shot and killed Michael Brown in Ferguson, Mo.

Eschert is white. She referenced reports of another police shooting near Ferguson that said a white person was the victim. She wrote on her personal Facebook page:

“Where is Obama? Where is Holder? Where is Al Sharpton? Where are Trayvon Martin’s parents? Where are all the white guy supporters? So WHY is everyone MAKING it a racial issue?!? So tired of hearing it’s a racial thing. If you are a thug and worthless to society, it’s not race – You’re just a waste no matter what religion, race or sex you are!”

Eschert did not identify herself as a Charlotte Fire Department employee, but she was fired in September after someone emailed the post to city officials. Carlee said it was discriminatory and inflammatory.

Guy Charles has a different phrase for it. He co-directs Duke University’s Center on Law, Race and Politics.

“She said something that at best was racially insensitive, but on a public issue on a private page,” Charles said. “Between the hand that she’s holding and the hand that the city’s holding, I think I’d prefer to have her hand.”

If Eschert worked for a private employer, she wouldn’t have a free speech case since the First Amendment only applies to the government. Even though she has that protection, though, it’s not absolute.

“I’m inclined to say the employee has a pretty strong case here, but when it comes to the government acting as an employer, the legal rules are quite vague,” UCLA Law Professor Eugene Volokh said.

“The Supreme Court has agreed that, on the one hand, the government doesn’t have a free hand in restricting speech by its employees. That any such restrictions would unduly interfere with public debate and democratic self-government and the marketplace of ideas,” Volokh said. “On the other hand, the court has said, but of course, the government may in some measure restrict speech in order to protect its efficiency.”

In other words, it’s a balancing act between the employee’s free speech and how disruptive that speech is to the city’s operations. Volokh pointed out courts have ruled in favor of government agencies firing police officers for outright racist statements. He said Eschert’s case isn’t as clean cut.

“It’s not clear how far it extends to statements that might be seen as racially insensitive or even racially offensive, but are an important part of the debate about what the president is or is not doing and how we should deal with racial questions,” Volokh said.

Also, Eschert was a fire investigator, not a police officer with powers to arrest.

If this case goes to court, UNC Chapel Hill Law Professor William Marshall said the city would have to prove the statement affected her ability to do her job. He said he has his doubts the city would succeed.

“I don’t think that it could easily be shown that she thinks that there are certain elements of society that might be thuggish is an indication that she’s not qualified to be able to engage in arson investigations,” Marshall said.

The Charlotte Fire Department doesn’t give much guidance to employees about what’s considered unacceptable speech. Its social media policy says not to use “unprofessional communication” that could negatively impact the department’s reputation, interfere with its mission or negatively affect its employees.

“That would be a concern about a member of our department talking, communicating, posting something that could be perceived as offensive, or of difficult or harassing … that type of nature,” said the fire department’s spokesman, Rob Brisley.

Charles said courts have long had to balance First Amendment rights with maintaining a workplace free from racial discrimination. He expects they’ll deal with more of these situations as recent events such as the shootings of Trayvon Martin and Michael Brown have put race front and center in the national debate, while social media have made private speech very public. Clearly that burden won’t just be on the courts, though.

“Employees have to decide how much risk they want to take for expressing views that are either politically incorrect or racist,” Charles said. “And employers also have to decide how much can they monitor and how much can they control the private postings and messages of their employees on their private accounts.”

Eschert believes the city is making a big deal out of the Facebook post in retaliation for her expressing concerns to a City Council member about the conditions of a city building. She wouldn’t talk to WFAE, but her attorney said the city couldn’t fire her for whistle-blowing because that’s protected by the First Amendment, too.

Related stories from Raleigh News & Observer

HOMEPAGE

City to pay $90,000 for Fire Department consultant

December 18, 2014 02:31 PM

HOMEPAGE

Salisbury police officer fired for Facebook post

December 18, 2014 02:36 PM

HOMEPAGE

Fired investigator says city retaliated against her

December 18, 2014 02:31 PM

  Comments  

Videos

UNC’s Cam Johnson talks about Tar Heels’ mindset when Williamson went down

Bail-reform advocates dispute fairness of cash bail for low-level offenders

View More Video

Trending Stories

John Harris warned his father about legal red flags involving Bladen operative

February 20, 2019 02:13 PM

Zion Williamson injured during Duke-UNC game after foot blows through shoe

February 20, 2019 09:53 PM

Three observations from No. 8 North Carolina’s 88-72 road win over No. 1 Duke

February 21, 2019 02:18 AM

Zion Williamson injured as No. 1 Duke falls to No. 8 UNC

February 20, 2019 11:11 PM

Transgender woman has asked to be moved from a men’s prison. So far, NC has said no.

February 20, 2019 01:42 PM

Read Next

‘I had a comfort level’ with tainted Bladen County operative, Mark Harris says

Politics & Government

‘I had a comfort level’ with tainted Bladen County operative, Mark Harris says

By Ely Portillo and

Jim Morrill

    ORDER REPRINT →

February 21, 2019 09:39 AM

Here are updates from testimony at the North Carolina Board of Elections hearing on the November 2018 general midterm election & vote fraud allegations in 9th District race.

KEEP READING

Sign Up and Save

#ReadLocal

Get six months of free digital access to The News & Observer

SUBSCRIBE WITH GOOGLE

MORE LATEST NEWS

Harsh reality: Just like that, Duke faces life without Zion Williamson

Sports

Harsh reality: Just like that, Duke faces life without Zion Williamson

February 21, 2019 03:02 AM
Three observations from No. 8 North Carolina’s 88-72 road win over No. 1 Duke

Sports

Three observations from No. 8 North Carolina’s 88-72 road win over No. 1 Duke

February 21, 2019 02:18 AM
Sam’s Quik Shop property in Durham sold for $5 million

Business

Sam’s Quik Shop property in Durham sold for $5 million

February 21, 2019 10:37 AM
Syracuse coach Jim Boeheim reportedly struck and killed a man on Interstate

National

Syracuse coach Jim Boeheim reportedly struck and killed a man on Interstate

February 21, 2019 09:54 AM
Dawes, Mipso and other favorites coming to the NC Museum of Art’s 2019 concert series

Entertainment

Dawes, Mipso and other favorites coming to the NC Museum of Art’s 2019 concert series

February 21, 2019 10:00 AM
Pay $500 on a panhandling charge or sit in jail for five days. Should NC find a better way?

North Carolina

Pay $500 on a panhandling charge or sit in jail for five days. Should NC find a better way?

February 21, 2019 08:28 AM
Take Us With You

Real-time updates and all local stories you want right in the palm of your hand.

Icon for mobile apps

Raleigh News & Observer App

View Newsletters

Subscriptions
  • Start a Subscription
  • Customer Service
  • eEdition
  • Vacation Hold
  • Pay Your Bill
  • Rewards
Learn More
  • About Us
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletters
  • News in Education
  • Triangletoday.com
  • Legal Notices
Advertising
  • Advertise With Us
  • About Our Ads
  • Place a Classified
  • Local Deals
  • N&O Store
  • N&O Photos
Copyright
Commenting Policy
Report News
Privacy Policy
Terms of Use


Back to Story