Why West Ham's Dramatic Equalizer Against Arsenal Was Controversially Ruled Out
Arsenal fans had their heads in their hands as referee Chris Kavanagh confirmed Callum Wilson's 95th-minute strike had crossed the line.
After a scramble following a corner, Wilson lashed home a fierce strike which was comfortably over the line by the time it was deflected away, but a furious Mikel Arteta made it clear he did not think the goal should stand.
A lengthy VAR review was needed to reach a verdict on a decision that could easily be remembered as the defining moment of the season. Awarding a goal would have invited Manchester City back into the Premier League title race, while striking it out would leave Arsenal in control and also deal a hammerblow to West Ham's survival hopes.
The final decision was made, chalking the goal off and letting Arsenal escape from London Stadium with a 1–0 victory.
Why West Ham's Goal Was Ruled Out
Arteta, using some superhuman vision, was quick to gesture that goalkeeper David Raya had been impeded by West Ham striker Pablo.
Replays showed Pablo had his arm across the chest of Raya, who went to ground in dramatic fashion shortly after. The focus on the VAR review centered around questions as to whether Pablo had grabbed Raya's arm and impacted the Arsenal stopper's ability to claim the ball, which he had failed to deal with in the first place.
A pitchside review of the incident was recommended and the referee ultimately decided that Pablo had unfairly impacted Raya's ability to claim the ball.
As a result, Arsenal were awarded a free kick, giving them a platform to see out a nervy victory.
#WHUARS – 90+5' VAR OVERTURN
- Premier League Match Centre (@PLMatchCentre) May 10, 2026
After VAR review, the referee overturned the original decision of goal to West Ham United.
Referee announcement: "After review, West Ham number 19 commits a foul on the goalkeeper. Final decision is direct free kick."
The Controversy Behind the Decision
Fans on social media were stunningly quick to highlight a similar incident from all the way back in the first gameweek of the season.
Arsenal beat Manchester United 1–0 at Old Trafford with a header from Riccardo Calafiori 13 minutes into the game. Altay Bayındır, United's starting goalkeeper on the day, immediately protested the goal and argued he had been impeded by William Saliba.
Footage of the incident appeared to show Saliba grabbing the arm of Bayındır, but no foul was given and Arsenal's goal was granted.
Questions will be asked over the consistency of the decisions which, given the fine margins, appear set to have a direct impact on the outcome of the Premier League title race.
READ THE LATEST SOCCER NEWS, ANALYSIS AND INSIGHT FROM SI FC
- Arsenal Player Ratings vs. West Ham: The Biggest VAR Call in Premier League History
- Why Kylian Mbappe Isn't Playing for Real Madrid vs. Barcelona
- Why Lamine Yamal Isn't Playing for Barcelona vs. Real Madrid
- Barcelona Confirm Death of Hansi Flick's Father Before El Clasico
- Jose Mourinho Issues Clear Response to Real Madrid Interest-But There's a Catch
This article was originally published on www.si.com as Why West Ham's Dramatic Equalizer Against Arsenal Was Controversially Ruled Out.
Copyright ABG-SI LLC. SPORTS ILLUSTRATED is a registered trademark of ABG-SI LLC. All Rights Reserved.
This story was originally published May 10, 2026 at 2:15 PM.