Sam Genco, at age 19, narrowly survived one of the United States’ worst military aircraft carrier fires. Today, 50 years later, it’s that ship’s drinking water he says could be killing him.
Genco was diagnosed last year at a North Carolina veterans’ clinic with ischemic heart disease – a common condition the federal government says is linked to Agent Orange exposure. He suffers from severely blocked arteries, cutting off the normal flow of oxygen and blood to the heart.
“It’s fatigue. Your muscles just don’t want to work. Like an engine full of sludge,” Genco said. “The engine keeps working harder but going slower.”
But the 69-year-old can’t get disability benefits tied to exposure to the herbicide Agent Orange.
If the federal government approved his claim, Genco could receive full disability benefits, which would increase his monthly veteran’s benefit check from about $1,400 to more than $3,000. Full disability benefits also have tax advantages and would improve his wife’s health care coverage. Despite no acknowledgment from the government that he was exposed to Agent Orange, Genco does get free medical treatment, like other veterans, at veterans’ clinics.
His bid for financial help is caught in a bureaucratic maze and a struggle involving widespread disagreement among experts about why he’s sick.
90,000 estimate of blue water U.S. veterans from Vietnam
Genco, who lives in Pine Knoll Shores, North Carolina, is one of an estimated 90,000 affected “blue water Navy Vietnam veterans,” named for the open seas and harbors where they served.
Federally funded research by the Institute of Medicine – now the National Academy of Medicine – concludes the sailors were possibly exposed to Agent Orange via their ships’ drinking water or from winds blowing the chemical out to sea.
The 2011 study, the most recent assessment, says the blue water controversy can’t be solved with science because the military didn’t track Agent Orange’s drift and presence in the water during the war.
The Department of Veterans Affairs wants more evidence before it will award the sailors benefits – even if their health problems mirror conditions known to have been caused by Agent Orange. Under pressure from veterans, the department has made some exceptions for blue-water sailors who have non-Hodgkin lymphoma or who temporarily were on land in Vietnam or whose ships docked close to shore.
All of them came back greasy. You had to wash these planes all the way down. And they kept telling us we were not exposed.
Nelson Lee, Vietnam blue water U.S. veteran
VA Secretary David Shulkin told McClatchy in a statement the department will continue its review of the blue-water sailors topic and “will be guided by the relevant science in determining any recommendations concerning this important issue.”
At first, Genco said, he was in disbelief that Agent Orange had caused his heart disease.
He’d heard only about the cancer-causing chemical dioxin in Agent Orange effectively poisoning the soldiers who had fought on land in Vietnam. He knew about the Air Force pilots and mechanics assigned to planes that extensively sprayed the herbicide on dense jungles, crops and forests in the region.
The U.S. military used Agent Orange during Operation Ranch Hand from 1962 to 1971 to eliminate heavily forested areas where enemy combatants might have been hiding and to wipe out food sources for the Viet Cong army. Some children and grandchildren of both the U.S. veterans and the people of Vietnam have well-documented birth defects associated with Agent Orange exposure.
Most U.S. veterans who served in Vietnam are eligible for presumptive Agent Orange-related disability benefits, meaning the federal government thinks there’s a high likelihood that chemical exposure caused certain late-in-life health problems. Presumptive benefits means individual veterans don’t have to prove they came in direct contact with Agent Orange.
Like the blue-water sailors now, other service veterans have wound their way through the VA system and fought for Agent Orange benefits even after initially being denied and told there wasn’t evidence of exposure. In 2015, the VA relented for a small group of Air Force reservists who flew C-123 planes that had been used to spray Agent Orange.
VA officials told McClatchy they don’t know how many blue-water sailors have applied for or been denied Agent Orange-related disability benefits. Since 2010, the VA has added more than 300 Navy and Coast Guard vessels to expand the pool of eligible sailors. Veterans are eligible if there’s documentation that their ships docked close to shore or traveled in inland waterways.
“The book is never closed,” said Dr. Ralph Erickson, a 32-year Army veteran who’s chief consultant at the VA overseeing veteran post-deployment health issues.
Erickson and others are running a new health survey for Vietnam veterans, including blue-water sailors, to see whether there’s new information about Agent Orange-related illnesses. The results will be published next year, comparing Vietnam veterans’ health to that of their contemporaries in the civilian population as well as military personnel at the time who served elsewhere.
VA appeal denied
The everyday uses of water – “Bathing in it. Doing laundry in it. Cooking with it. Drinking it.” – are what Genco remembers about being aboard one of the Navy’s largest Vietnam wartime ships. Compared with other dangers in the South China Sea at the halfway point of the Vietnam War, the USS Forrestal’s drinking water, at the time, seemed innocuous.
Not the least of the dangers was the July 29, 1967, fire on the aircraft carrier, caused when a rocket misfire triggered a chain reaction of exploding bombs. The blasts left giant holes in the Forrestal’s flight deck, where Genco worked 12-hour days, sliding under the bellies of combat planes to ready them for takeoff.
With the fire raging, Genco and other sailors heaved heavy bombs over the side of the ship to try to contain the catastrophe. He was spared, but 134 other crew members were killed and 161 were injured.
“That was before we had body bags,” Genco said. “There were just bodies on the deck. Burnt to a crisp.”
Four months later, he left the war zone, thinking he’d escaped the worst of what Vietnam could do to him.
A fellow Navy veteran in North Carolina, Nelson Lee, understands.
Lee, 74, also has ischemic heart disease, as well as tinnitus – or ringing in the ears – plus hearing loss, diabetes and service-related post-traumatic stress disorder.
For some of those conditions, Lee is classified as 40 percent disabled and the VA sends him a $644 check each month.
He’s been denied benefits for the heart disease he says Agent Orange caused. If Lee’s application for 100 percent service-related disability were approved, he estimates, he’d see at least a $3,000 monthly check.
Lee was a skinny, 120-pound 19-year-old from Kannapolis, then a small textile town near Charlotte, when he enlisted in the Navy in 1962. He remembers that the towels sailors used on Navy ships came from the town’s Cannon Mill, once the largest manufacturer of textiles in the world.
On the aircraft carrier USS Independence, he worked on the flight deck, servicing the planes for bombing missions. He’d check the oil, wash the windshield, strap in the pilot, remove the tie-downs from the plane and give the signal to start the engines.
“All of them came back greasy. You had to wash these planes all the way down. And they kept telling us we were not exposed,” Lee recalled of planes from his carrier that didn’t have herbicide loads but came back covered with what he believes was Agent Orange.
$1.1 billion cost trips up Congress
The government doesn’t acknowledge the sailors were exposed.
The U.S. study in 2011 found that the Navy ships’ distillation system would have enriched and concentrated dioxin in drinking water, rather than expelling the Agent Orange chemical. The findings considered a similar 2002 study done in Australia that resulted in that country compensating its blue-water sailors for dioxin exposure.
Veterans groups often point to the Australian study to boost their arguments.
The blue-water sailors issue laid dormant at the VA for a decade after the 1991 Agent Orange Act passed Congress, granting broad authority to the department to fast-track presumptive exposure claims from veterans, including sailors. Then, in 2002, the VA ruled for the first time there was insufficient evidence that blue-water sailors had been exposed.
The change drew ire from Republicans and Democrats alike in Congress. Multiple bills that would force the VA’s hand have failed, with lawmakers vexed over how they would cover the estimated $1.1 billion cost associated with expanded presumptive benefits.
The U.S. House Veterans’ Affairs Committee has scheduled a hearing April 5 on the latest version of legislation that would provide blue-water sailors with Agent Orange benefits.
Meanwhile, the veterans are waiting for their day in court with a lawsuit pending against the government. Oral arguments in the case brought by the Blue Water Navy Vietnam Veterans Association are expected to start in federal court in May.
For now, the claims are handled case by case.
After being diagnosed with ischemic heart disease, Genco applied last year for 100 percent disability with the VA. His VA medical evaluations list Agent Orange factors and he has no family history of heart problems.
The VA hasn’t denied Genco’s claim but it’s unlikely he’ll be approved, because so far he hasn’t pointed to direct exposure to Agent Orange – except through the drinking-water research the VA has already knocked down.
Some members of Congress are renewing their calls for the VA to fix what they see as unfair treatment.
A bill that would grant the sailors presumptive benefits has 226 co-sponsors from both parties in the U.S. House of Representatives, including four from North Carolina: Reps. Walter Jones, David Rouzer and Richard Hudson – all Republicans – and Democrat Alma Adams.
In the U.S. Senate, there are 35 signatures on the bill. North Carolina’s Sens. Richard Burr and Thom Tillis, both Republicans, aren’t co-sponsors.
Tillis’ office didn’t respond to McClatchy’s request for information about his views.
Burr’s office said he supported veterans and a Senate committee handling the issue but didn’t say why he’s not a co-sponsor of the bill.
Attorney John Wells, himself a veteran and retired Navy commander who served for 22 years, has been on the case for more than a decade. He has a meeting scheduled April 21 with Shulkin, the first medical doctor to ever lead the Cabinet department.
“He could (extend the benefits) with the stroke of a pen,” Wells, from Louisiana, told McClatchy.
Even if Congress or the VA acts, it could take up to two years for blue-water sailors to start seeing Agent Orange benefits, due to the length of time it takes a federal department to form a regulation and get various levels of approval.
For Lee, who has been weaving his way through the VA system for several years, it’s hard to be hopeful.
“I’m just waiting to die,” he said. “I don’t think they’ll ever do anything.”