Politics & Government

Wavering Democrat sticks with party on abortion vote; Cotham votes with rest of GOP

Democratic Reps. Shelly Willingham and Garland Pierce talk on the floor of the North Carolina House before the House convened for its afternoon voting session on Wednesday, May 3, 2022.
Democratic Reps. Shelly Willingham and Garland Pierce talk on the floor of the North Carolina House before the House convened for its afternoon voting session on Wednesday, May 3, 2022. tlong@newsobserver.com

READ MORE


Abortion in North Carolina

Republicans in the North Carolina state legislature passed a law that implements new abortion restrictions. What does that mean for access to abortion? Read coverage on the issue from The News & Observer and The Charlotte Observer.

Expand All

Hours before a vote Wednesday night on the GOP’s fast-moving 12-week abortion ban, a Democratic lawmaker said he still hadn’t decided how he’d vote.

But Rep. Garland Pierce ended up voting against the legislation, as did every other Democrat who cast a vote.

Every Republican who voted, meanwhile, supported the bill. That included Rep. Tricia Cotham, who as a Democrat had campaigned on supporting Roe v. Wade. Cotham switched parties last month.

Rep. Tricia Cotham, a Mecklenburg County Republican and former Democrat, speaks on a bill on the House floor prior to voting in favor of the the new abortion restrictions bill Wednesday, May 3, 2023 at the Legislative Building.
Rep. Tricia Cotham, a Mecklenburg County Republican and former Democrat, speaks on a bill on the House floor prior to voting in favor of the the new abortion restrictions bill Wednesday, May 3, 2023 at the Legislative Building. Travis Long tlong@newsobserver.com

Three House members were absent.

Pierce, a Baptist minister who represents Scotland and Hoke counties, told The News & Observer that as of Wednesday morning, he hadn’t ruled anything out and planned to make a final decision after carefully reviewing the full bill and hearing debate this afternoon on the House floor.

“If I make a decision, I want to make it on the facts,” Pierce said in an interview.

The 46-page bill detailing the GOP proposal — a ban on abortions after 12 weeks of pregnancy with exceptions for rape and incest, fetal anomalies and the life of the mother, coupled with restrictions on medication abortions, and millions of dollars in funding for child care, foster care, contraception, paid parental leave for teachers and state employees and adoption — was publicly released late Tuesday night.

Less than 24 hours later, the bill had passed the House and was on to the Senate for a vote expected Thursday.

Pierce, who is one of a few House Democrats who are considered swing votes due to their willingness to vote with Republicans on certain bills, said earlier Wednesday he hadn’t yet had a chance to go through the entire bill.

Rep. Garland Pierce a Hoke and Scotland County Democrat listens to debate on an abortion restriction bill at the State Legislature Building on Wednesday, May 3, 2022. Pierce, considered a swing vote, voted against the bill.
Rep. Garland Pierce a Hoke and Scotland County Democrat listens to debate on an abortion restriction bill at the State Legislature Building on Wednesday, May 3, 2022. Pierce, considered a swing vote, voted against the bill.

House Republicans have said throughout this year’s session that a small number of Democrats had indicated to them their support for various issues on the GOP agenda.

During a Tuesday evening press conference, Rep. Sarah Stevens, a high-ranking member of House Republican leadership, reiterated that there are some Democrats whom Republicans have talked to about the bill, and who “might” end up supporting it.

Here’s the legislature’s list of how everyone in the House voted Wednesday night.

Yes votes (Republican): Adams; Arp; K. Baker; Balkcom; Bell; Biggs; Blackwell; Bradford; Brisson; Brody; Cairns; Chesser; Clampitt; Cleveland; Cotham; Crutchfield; Dixon; Elmore; Faircloth; Fontenot; Gillespie; Goodwin; Greene; D. Hall; K. Hall; Hardister; Hastings; Howard; Humphrey; Iler; N. Jackson; Johnson; B. Jones; Kidwell; Lambeth; Loftis; Lowery; McNeely; Miller; Mills; Moore (Speaker); Moss; Paré; Penny; Pickett; Pike; Pless; Potts; Pyrtle; Reeder; Riddell; Ross; Saine; Sasser; Sauls; Setzer; Shepard; C. Smith; Sossamon; Stevens; Strickland; Torbett; Tyson; Ward; Warren; Watford; Wheatley; White; Willis; Winslow; Zenger

No votes (Republican): None

Excused Absence (Republican): Davis

No votes (Democrat): Ager; Alexander; Alston; Autry; Ball; Belk; Brockman; Brown; G. Brown; K. Brown; Buansi; Budd; Butler; Carney; Cervania; Charles Smith; Clemmons; Crawford; Cunningham; Dahle; Everitt; Gill; Harris; Harrison; Hawkins; F. Jackson; Jeffers; John; A. Jones; Liu; Lofton; Logan; Longest; Majeed; Morey; Pierce; Prather; Price; Quick; Reives; Roberson; Rudow; Staton-Williams; von Haefen; Willingham; Wray

Yes votes (Democrat): None

Excused absence (Democrat): A. Baker; Lucas

This story was originally published May 3, 2023 at 11:32 AM.

CORRECTION: A previous version of this story said incorrectly that the abortion bill contains crisis pregnancy center funding.

Corrected May 3, 2023
Related Stories from Raleigh News & Observer
Avi Bajpai
The News & Observer
Avi Bajpai is a state politics reporter for The News & Observer. He previously covered breaking news and public safety. Contact him at abajpai@newsobserver.com or (919) 346-4817.
Get unlimited digital access
#ReadLocal

Try 1 month for $1

CLAIM OFFER

Abortion in North Carolina

Republicans in the North Carolina state legislature passed a law that implements new abortion restrictions. What does that mean for access to abortion? Read coverage on the issue from The News & Observer and The Charlotte Observer.